The Math Forum

Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Math Forum » Discussions » Inactive » comp.soft-sys.math.mathematica

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: manipulating equations
Replies: 0  

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List  
Roman Maeder

Posts: 8
Registered: 12/4/04
manipulating equations
Posted: Jan 8, 1998 11:54 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply


this little utility was originally developer for DMUG, the German
Mathematica User Group ( It answers a
frequently asked question about the manipulation of equations.
Mathematica does not "thread" arithmetic and other functions over
equations, so the following naive approach to solving equations by
rearranging terms does not work:

In[1]:= 1 + x == 2

In[2]:= %-1

Out[2]= -1 + (1 + x == 2)

To make it work, the symbol Equal (the head of an equation) should
behave like List with respect to listable functions. Just as {a, b} + 1
turns into {a+1, b+1}, one may want (a==b) + 1 to turn into a+1 == b+1.
This can be achieved explicitly with Thread:

In[3]:= Thread[(a==b) + 1, Equal]

Out[3]= 1 + a == 1 + b

The automatic transformation of f[a, b, c, ...] into Thread[f[a, b, c,
...]] should happen whenever f has the attribute Listable and at least
one of the arguments a, b, ... has head Equal. This definition is
essentially what is needed:

Equal/: lhs:f_Symbol?listableQ[___, _Equal, ___] :=
Thread[ Unevaluated[lhs], Equal ]

listableQ[f_] := MemberQ[Attributes[f], Listable]

The use of "Unevaluated" prevents an infinite recursion. Together with
the necessary framework, please find attached the little package
EqualThread.m that implements this functionality.

Now, you can solve equation as you did in school:

read the package:

In[1]:= Needs["EqualThread`"]

the equation, to be solved for x:

In[7]:= a == b Log[2 x]

divide by b:

In[8]:= %/b

Out[8]= - == Log[2 x]


In[9]:= Exp[%]

Out[9]= E == 2 x

divide by 2:

In[10]:= %/2

Out[10]= ---- == x

You can also add equations, etc.:

In[11]:= (a==b) + (c==d)

Out[11]= a + c == b + d

Roman Mdder

MathConsult Dr. R. Mdder Samstagernstrasse 58a
Computer-Aided Mathematics 8832 Wollerau, Switzerland

T: +41-1-687 4051
F: +41-1-687 4054
Content-Description: EqualThread.m

(* :Title: make equations behave like lists *)

(* :Author: Roman E. Maeder *)

(* :Summary:
make listable functions thread over equations as they do over lists.
Allows for easy manipulation of equations. *)

(* :Context: EqualThread` *)

(* :Package Version: 1.1 *)

(* :Copyright: ) Copyright 1997, Roman E. Maeder.

Permission is granted to use and distribute this file for any purpose
except for inclusion in commercial software or program collections.
This copyright notice must remain intact. *)

(* :History:
Version 1.1 for mathgroup and MathSource, January 1998.
Version 1.0 for DMUG (German Mathematica User Group), January 1998.

(* :Keywords:
Equal, equation solving, threading *)

(* :Warning: Adds definitions to the built-in symbol System`Equal. *)

(* :Mathematica Version:3.0 *)


(* no exports *)


listableQ[f_] := MemberQ[Attributes[f], Listable]

protected = Unprotect[Equal]

Equal/: lhs:f_Symbol?listableQ[___, _Equal, ___] :=
Thread[ Unevaluated[lhs], Equal ]





Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2018. All Rights Reserved.