Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.


Luis A. Afonso
Posts:
4,758
From:
LIsbon (Portugal)
Registered:
2/16/05


Cohen´s d and the current NHST
Posted:
Dec 31, 2012 12:45 PM


Cohen´s d and the current NHST
Facing an observed pair of mean values <x> and <y> Jacob Cohen (19231998) knows two things: ____1_____Each one is liable to have random fluctuations, ____2_____The difference, or each one mean, should be scaled by a standard deviation. If fact he got that a large difference <x>  <y> for very dispersive data is much less important/significant than for a very close together one. So, he defines a ´suitable difference (my say) ´ as ______d= (<x>  <y>)/s (Cohen?s d). And because he had no idea how to define s: ascribing to the undisturbed y or to the treated x or both, left it to the reader?s expertise to chose. No matter, Wikipedia states he is famous by the find . . . supposedly he was the first psychologist to think about . . . No important . . . This and other avatars I come to know about NHST is that Statistics teachers did not emphasize that a single term change all things, namely _______W= (<x>  <y>  D)/s , When the shift D is considered as a constant W it follows the same distribution than the difference <x>  <y> and in consequence one is immediately liable to calculate a Confidence interval for D at a preset level. Cohen as an inventor . . .
Luis A. Afonso
Happy new Year . . .



