Wayne Bishop posted Aug 9, 2013 9:45 PM (http://mathforum.org/kb/message.jspa?messageID=9189701): > At 11:45 PM 8/8/2013, Richard Strausz wrote: > >Sorry GS, I wasn't clear. I was addressing Wayne. > > That's okay but "genuflecting to Wayne" would be more > appropriate. > After having duly (and humbly) genuflected to Wayne and the other gods that are, I believe the question posed by Howard Gardner in his interview has not yet been adequately answered (after well over 30 postings at this thread; after hundreds or even thousands of investigations elsewhere). The question is:
"How do we preserve the imagination and the questioning of the 5-year-old mind, but replace the child's notions with well-founded theories and accurate conceptions?"
I'm NOT suggesting by any means that Howard Gardner (HG) has come out with the definitive answer to this question - except that he has provided us some useful ideas in his work on *'multiple intelligences'*. (*I believe that it would be more appropriate and accurate to think in terms of *'multiple dimensions of human intelligence'*. Though HG's *'multiple intelligences'* could possibly be justified - and he has I believed tried to justify - it is probably not worth the hassle, so I'll go with those *'multiple dimensions of human intelligence'*).
I further tend to disagree with Howard Gardner about his notions that we have a great many "well-founded theories and accurate conceptions" to replace what a child develops through naturally growing up - and I observe that much of what that child later develops (via conventional education imposed on him/her by us adults) is alas fatally flawed by our adult views of the world. [Howls of adult outrage - see below].
I AM claiming that our conventional mode of thinking about and discussing complex issues is severely flawed.
I DO claim that children do a far better job of ^'growing up'^ in the world we provide to them than do we adults in 'operating' it. (After the howls of outrage from angry adults have subsided a bit, check out "How a Child Learns", attached herewith).
[^Unfortunately for those children - all children - they are forced to 'grow up' into being flawed adults like ourselves. (More howls of outrage, doubtless)].