Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math.independent

Topic: Platonism, criticism
Replies: 135   Last Post: Apr 17, 2014 11:06 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
David Petry

Posts: 1,103
Registered: 12/8/04
Re: Platonism, criticism
Posted: Apr 14, 2014 3:32 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

On Monday, April 14, 2014 9:17:07 AM UTC-7, Jim Burns wrote:
> On 4/14/2014 11:16 AM, mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de wrote:

> > Actual infinity implies a contradiction.

> This is the sort of claim that I have been looking for.

So even though you deny being a Platonist, you act like one.


> > A set of numbers
> > is "proven" uncountable by constructing or defining another number
> > that, together with the former, belongs to a countable set.
> > The proof that all constructable and definable numbers belong
> > to a countable set is circumvented by asserting the existence
> > of undefinable numbers.



> I should give you credit for knowing that this is wrong,
> I suppose. That means that you are blatantly lying.


> That spoils the fun for me, [...]


I too have trouble deciphering WM's argument. So let me
present an argument that I *think* is close to the argument
the he is trying to present.

In the language I am using here, the only things that "exist"
are things that are provably well defined. Let's say that a
real number is provably well defined iff we have a proof that
every digit of the number can actually be computed. And let's
say that a list of real numbers is provably well defined iff
we have a proof that for all n and m, the n'th digit of the
m'th real number in the list can actually be computed. Then
the diagonal argument gives us a way to construct a provably
well defined real number not on the list. However, that does
not imply that it's meaningful to say that there exists a
collection of all real numbers, and especially, it does not
imply that there "exist" uncountable collections of real
numbers.



Date Subject Author
4/8/14
Read Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
scattered
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
scattered
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Peter Percival
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jens Stuckelberger
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/8/14
Read constructivism
Brian Q. Hutchings
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Bill Taylor
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/10/14
Read infantilism
Brian Q. Hutchings
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/11/14
Read criticism
Brian Q. Hutchings
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Peter Percival
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/10/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Martin Shobe
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/13/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/13/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/13/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/13/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/13/14
Read Natural languages are equi-interpretable Re: Platonism, criticism
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Brian Q. Hutchings
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/16/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/16/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/17/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/17/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/17/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
mueckenh@rz.fh-augsburg.de
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/15/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/14/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/13/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Roland Franzius
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Virgil
4/11/14
Read Falsifiability is scientific doctrine, Re: Platonism, criticism
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/12/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/13/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/13/14
Read Hancher as conservatively standard, Re: Platonism, criticism
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Jim Burns
4/9/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
David Petry
4/8/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
4/11/14
Read Re: Platonism, criticism
Eduardo J. Donglemeier

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.