The Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: 0 = 1
Replies: 101   Last Post: Oct 6, 2017 12:07 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
FredJeffries@gmail.com

Posts: 1,837
Registered: 11/29/07
Re: 0 = 1
Posted: Sep 23, 2017 12:41 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

On Saturday, September 23, 2017 at 9:10:59 AM UTC-7, Dan Christensen laid down the law:

> If you cannot formally define these concepts of yours purely in terms of the symbols of logic and set theory (or some equivalent), it isn't mathematics.

That's ridiculous. You have just chauvinistically declared the mathematics of thousands of years and hundreds of cultures to be "n[o]t mathematics"; not to mention all of the experimental and not-yet-formalized current research; not to mention all of the checkbook balancing done by millions of people who never saw a "symbol of logic" in their lives.


Date Subject Author
9/6/17
Read 0 = 1
conway
9/6/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Karl-Olav Nyberg
9/6/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Jens Stuckelberger
9/6/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Bill
9/6/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Me
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Karl-Olav Nyberg
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
zelos.malum@outlook.com
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
dylan.youngers@gmail.com
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
zelos.malum@outlook.com
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Markus Klyver
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Bill
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/7/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Bill
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/8/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Markus Klyver
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FromTheRafters
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FromTheRafters
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FromTheRafters
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Bill
10/4/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
bassam king karzeddin
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/20/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/21/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/21/17
Read 0 = 1
William Elliot
9/21/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/21/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
9/22/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Markus Klyver
9/22/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/22/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Karl-Olav Nyberg
9/22/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Markus Klyver
9/22/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Me
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Me
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Me
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FredJeffries@gmail.com
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FredJeffries@gmail.com
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Me
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FredJeffries@gmail.com
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FredJeffries@gmail.com
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Dan Christensen
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Me
9/24/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
FredJeffries@gmail.com
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Peter Percival
9/23/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Markus Klyver
9/21/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
conway
10/6/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
zelos.malum@gmail.com
10/6/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Conway
9/21/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Markus Klyver
9/21/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
Bill
9/21/17
Read Re: 0 = 1
7777777

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2017. All Rights Reserved.