The Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Replies: 36   Last Post: Oct 9, 2017 1:27 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
jsavard@ecn.ab.ca

Posts: 403
Registered: 12/12/04
Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Posted: Oct 3, 2017 10:02 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

On Monday, October 2, 2017 at 6:41:47 PM UTC-6, mitchr...@gmail.com wrote:

> Math is going forward to a simplified new.

It is true that the original concept of numbers was to answer the question
"How many?", and while you can have three of something, or none of that same
thing, you can't really have a negative quantity of anything - only a quantity
of some different thing which, in some sense, is opposite to the original
thing.

So a debt of one dollar is not the exact opposite of a dollar bill.

However, in areas where the concept of negative numbers is still useful,
nothing is made simpler - things just become more complicated and awkward - if
we give up negative numbers and the ability to do arithmetic with them.

Saying that for clarity mathematicians should admit that complex numbers *and
even negative numbers* aren't unproblematically part of the original concept
of number, but are instead extensions to that concept *is valid*; expecting
these extensions to be dispensed with is not.

John Savard


Date Subject Author
9/30/17
Read No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
9/30/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Dan Christensen
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Me
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
jsavard@ecn.ab.ca
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/4/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/6/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
zelos.malum@gmail.com
10/4/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
zelos.malum@gmail.com
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Dan Christensen
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Dan Christensen
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Me
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/4/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Me
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Dan Christensen
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Dan Christensen
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Dan Christensen
10/3/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/9/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Me
9/30/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Me
9/30/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
zelos.malum@gmail.com
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Me
10/2/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
zelos.malum@gmail.com
10/6/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Markus Klyver
10/6/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/6/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
Markus Klyver
10/6/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/9/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
zelos.malum@gmail.com
10/9/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com
10/9/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
zelos.malum@gmail.com
10/9/17
Read Re: No Below Zero... or a name for the absence of quantity...
mitchrae3323@gmail.com

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2017. All Rights Reserved.