Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: POW response
Replies: 0

 Catherine Wester Posts: 6 Registered: 12/3/04
POW response
Posted: Jul 17, 1997 11:14 AM

This group response includes the ideas of Rasheed, Debbie, Dianne, Willie
Mae, and Catherine.

PROBLEM:"The Emperor's Banquet"

You have been invited to the emperor's banquet. The emperor is a really
strange host. Instead of sitting with his guests at his large round dining
table, he walks around the table pouring oats on the head of every other
person. He continues this process. pouring oats on the head of everyone who
has not had oats until there is only one person left. This last person is
then allowed to join the emperor in his grand feast. The question is, where
should you sit if you do not want oats poured on your head?

>
>What is your answer? How did you get it? Did you all agree?

We are not going to give any of our answers. We feel that the terms of the
problem could be defined in so many ways that the possibilities are too
numerous to list or show here.

We did work out a number of solutions. First, we tried to solve the
problem individually as a brain teaser (mentally). In checking our
solutions, we decided that none of us had considered all of the
defining terms and the "King's process" too many solutions were possible.
The biggest stumbling block was in defining the "King's process" and in a
sense the problem became insoluable, because if one was to determine the
best place to sit so that they might then dine with the king, it would be
possible to do this only if you read the king's mind or else had attended a
number of these banquets and saw that he always proceeded in the same
fashion.

YES!
>
>What are similar problems that you have used in your classroom?

A similar problem (in the sense that they are thought provoking) are:
"A person has two coins, one in each hand. If added together, the sum of
the two coins is \$0.55. One of the coins is not a nickel. What are the
two coins?"
>
>How would you use this problem in your classroom?

We think that we would proceed in class much as we did today: dividing the
children into groups and allowing them to define the problem and seek
various solutions.
>
>How would you change this problem if you were going to use it?

If we wanted to reduce the frustration level, we might give more definition
to the problem ourselves.
>
>How does this problem fit in with your current curricular focus or
>focuses? (patterns, functions, and problem solving, cooperative
>learning, or whatever)

It would fit all these foci.
>
>After you've done a bit of this writing, take a look at the solutions
>submitted by students and talk about them in your group. What do you
>see?

There seems to be a correct solution.

Do you hear anything surprising to you?

Yes, there seems to be a correct solution.

Do you see things that you