Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Inactive » k12.ed.math

Topic: rote learning math facts
Replies: 51   Last Post: Aug 23, 2002 6:38 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Mark Houghton

Posts: 82
Registered: 12/6/04
Re: rote learning math facts
Posted: Aug 16, 2002 6:18 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

In article <1fvplug8s2676lf59pcseo1mu0qochhbjt@4ax.com>, Paul Tanner
<uprho@yahoo.com> writes
>And Mark, it is always the case that we can find a problem that
>baffles a group of students (or people in general) that are not Ph.D's
>in mathematics with a specialty in the area of the problem. The way I
>see it, sooner or later we'll have to be satisfied with a certain
>measured performance level.


I know that this first statement is true, but I chose this particular
question with intent. It tests understanding of the concepts of mean and
s.d., rather then the ability to calculate them. If you don't understand
what mean and s.d *are*, what use is the ability to calculate them?

Why do you think that British children, who are able to calculate these
quantities, can't demostrate that they understand what they mean? One
answer is this: in selecting the appropriate bits of knowledge to
impart, teachers have seen, from experience that the "important" thing
to teach (ie the one that will pass tests) is the calculation. And, as
far as this goes, they are right.

Suddenly, the exam board asks a (very good, I think) question, and
students who in any other year "understood" statistical measures, now
don't. This shows one of the difficulties ofusing standardized tests as
a "scientific measure of knowledge".

I was interested in what you had to say about innate "mathematical
talent". I do think that's an interesting area of discussion - and very
problematic. But "mathematical talent" begs for a definition.

I'd really like to have the time to discuss your post in full, as it
raises so many interesting points, but as I'm trying to move countries
ATM, there are just a couple of things more I'd like to probe.

First, by what mechanism do you think that "science [can] set some of
our goals"? This seems an odd concept. Kind of like letting a hammer
design a house ;-)

Finally, I don't think that anyone here is arguing that memorization is
bad, or wrong. The question is how to *achieve* memorization (and,
Brian, don't you think that capital cities which you've visited are
easier to remember than those you once read in a list at school ;-).

The quibble is with "rote".
M.
--
Mark Houghton
mark@mhark.demon.co.uk

--
submissions: post to k12.ed.math or e-mail to k12math@sd28.bc.ca
private e-mail to the k12.ed.math moderator: kem-moderator@thinkspot.net
newsgroup website: http://www.thinkspot.net/k12math/
newsgroup charter: http://www.thinkspot.net/k12math/charter.html




Date Subject Author
8/1/02
Read rote learning math facts
Art Burke
8/2/02
Read Reply to "rote learning math facts"
Kim Mackey
8/4/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts"
Dr. David J. Ritchie, Sr.
8/4/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts
mattsmom
8/4/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts
Kevin Killion
8/5/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts
Brian Harvey
8/5/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts
Chergarj
8/6/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts
mattsmom
8/4/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/4/02
Read Re: Reply to "rote learning math facts
Bob
8/8/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Art Burke
8/8/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Chergarj
8/8/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Art Burke
8/9/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/9/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Brian Harvey
8/10/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Mark Houghton
8/12/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/12/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/12/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Brian Harvey
8/13/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/14/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Brian Harvey
8/14/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
mattsmom
8/14/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Mark Houghton
8/15/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Rhombus
8/15/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Rhombus
8/16/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Dr. David J. Ritchie, Sr.
8/16/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
mattsmom
8/17/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Brian Harvey
8/16/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/16/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Mark Houghton
8/17/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Brian Harvey
8/18/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/18/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Mark Houghton
8/19/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/17/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Brian Harvey
8/18/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Paul A. Tanner III
8/17/02
Read Re: rote learning math facts
Michael Greene
8/17/02
Read Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?
mattsmom
8/17/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?
Nat Silver
8/18/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?"
mattsmom
8/18/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?"
Nat Silver
8/18/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?"
Mark Houghton
8/19/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?""
mattsmom
8/22/02
Read Is winning timed-competitions the goal of
Haim
8/22/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of
Brian Harvey
8/23/02
Read Is winning timed-competitions the goal of
Haim
8/22/02
Read Is winning timed-competitions the goal of
mattsmom
8/23/02
Read Is winning timed-competitions the goal of
Haim
8/19/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?"
Michael Greene
8/17/02
Read Re: Is winning timed-competitions the goal of math-education?
Michael Greene

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.