Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: NCTM C&E K-4 Stds XII (June 29)
Replies: 8   Last Post: Jan 5, 2004 2:16 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Kreg A. Sherbine Posts: 26 Registered: 12/6/04
Re: NCTM C&E K-4 Stds XII (June 29)
Posted: Jun 30, 1996 11:05 AM

On Sat, 29 Jun 1996, Ronald A Ward wrote:
<stuff deleted>
> 66. In discussing place value, I am aware that many writers put off
> discussing the teens in this context because of the way we "say" the teen
> numbers. But I once saw an interesting approach [from Wayne Peterson of
> the Seattle Public Schools, I believe] which though humorously presented
> does have considerable merit. Note how we pronounce "40, 60, 70, 80, and
> 90." To be consistent, we should say "twoty, threety, fivety" for "20,
> 30, 50." Now note what that does for the teens: "13" becomes
> "onety-three" for example. Makes much more sense to me from a place value

Interesting, Ron. This reminds me of other place-value based ways of
talking; for example, we say "twelve sixty-five" in reference to a
certain number of dollars and a certain number of cents. And phrases
like "fourscore and seven" used to be common. I wonder whether
forty-five is an abbreviation of "four tens and five." Karen Dee?

If so, it might make sense to approach place value from the assumption
that ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny: we (collectively) used to refer to
a certain number as four tens and five; perhaps in writing this was
shortened to 4T5; and the language evolved (as it so often does) from our
common use of it. Thirteen (ten and three) and other teens (tens)
probably have a good reason for being "backwards;" again, hearing from
the historians on this would be helpful. As Ron says, it would probably
be really good for kids' development of number sense to get them involved
in the evolution of the terminology. (Bonus points for anyone who can
explain eleven.)

Kreg A. Sherbine | To doubt everything or to believe
Apollo Middle School | everything are two equally convenient
Nashville, Tennessee | solutions; both dispense with the
sherbine@math.vanderbilt.edu | necessity of reflection. -H. Poincare

Date Subject Author
6/29/96 Ronald A Ward
6/29/96 Mansel A. Nelson
6/30/96 G. RAY MEESTER
6/30/96 Daniel Ray DIALUP
6/30/96 Mansel A. Nelson
6/30/96 Mansel A. Nelson
1/5/04 Teresa
1/5/04 Ralph A. Raimi
6/30/96 Kreg A. Sherbine