Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Re: Standards
Replies: 2   Last Post: Oct 15, 1995 11:43 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Michael Paul Goldenberg Posts: 7,041 From: Ann Arbor, MI Registered: 12/3/04
Re: Standards
Posted: Oct 14, 1995 1:42 PM

At 10:27 AM 10/14/95, Andrei TOOM wrote:
>Look for example on p.139 of `Curriculum and Evaluation Standards'.
>It describes what is called a `Real-world problem situation'.
>Actually it is a certain game. In which sense is it `real-world' ?
>Who of you or your friends or relatives has ever played this game ?
>
>Another question about the same page:
>Some attempt of solution is dismissed in lines 5-7
>on the ground that it `has been determined to be inequitable'.
>Can you explain what the word `determined' means in this context ?
>
>Andrei Toom toom@the-college.iwctx.edu

I am afraid that once again, Andrei has drawn some rather questionable
conclusions.

First, the "real-world" situation is the distribution of pizza, not the
game. The game is a mathematical MODEL (one which is related in the text to
a famous problem solved by Fermat and Pascal). In the real world with which
I am familiar, questions of fair distribution of goods are a common
occurance. In schools, it's called "sharing." In the larger world, it's
connected to various questions of economics and economic systems. Some of
the latter include, supply-side capitalism, socialism, and communism. (Talk
about 'raising a red flag in front of a bull!)

Second, the mysterious word "determined" in this context probably means,
"somebody previously has figured out mathematically"; whether that somebody
is the class, the teachers, an expert mathematician, the author of a book,
or someone else is not made clear in the passage. The question is: why is
knowing who made that determination important IN THIS CONTEXT?

I would offer that Andrei's suggestion that there is something heinous
about the passage on pp.138-139 is unconvincing.

|---------------------------------------------------------------------------
|Michael Paul Goldenberg
|University of Michigan 310 E. Cross St.
|School of Education 4002 Ypsilanti, MI 48198
|Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1259 (313) 482-9585
|(313) 747-2244
|
|"Truth is a mobile army of metaphors."
|Friedrich Nietzsche
|---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Date Subject Author
10/14/95 Michael Paul Goldenberg
10/15/95 Andre TOOM
10/15/95 Michael Paul Goldenberg