Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Education » math-teach

Topic: Graphing Calculators
Replies: 39   Last Post: Nov 9, 1997 3:03 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
David Scott Powell

Posts: 54
Registered: 12/6/04
Re: Graphing Calculators
Posted: Oct 27, 1995 3:05 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Richard said:


In the middle school
>I am trying to get that kind of student to take responsibility for what
>they learn/don't learn by using a sort of "mastery" approach wherein I
>let them work on assignments in a chapter at their own pace until they
>think they are ready for chapter test; if they pass the chapter test I'll
>let them move on to the next chapter but not until they do. I do not
>give them calculators because they are working on 4th to 8th grade
>material (in an 8th grade class); I encourage them to get their own, and
>use them in class, but don't let them use them on tests, of course.



This is a very good point you make. I would like to change the focus
again(I believe Gary tried to point this out). Maybe if calculators are
going to be used then we need to change what we are asking for.
Computation has a perpose(less so now then say a hundred years ago) and
students need to have some sort of understanding of what is going on but
wrote arithmatic year after year after year(traditional elementary math) is
really counter-prductive IMHO. Why not ask interesting questions in which
students can use the calculator to explore and maybe the arithmatic will
come into play as the exploration is continued(you would be surprised how
often this happens). I am not saying do away with arithmatic, just to
incorperate it into interesting problems and situations that can be done
with the calculator(and the brain).





>
>I don't think it is just fear of the new or unknown that keeps people
>from going ahead rapidly into using technology extensively. It may be
>that for some people (and society) there are big benefits from more
>technology and for others (and society) there will be some losses. As
>technology is so increasingly present we need to encourage students to
>learn to use it without taking away the incontrovertable benefits of
>learning to manipulate numbers and symbols with the brains that are able
>to design and use new technology.


As the standards say we need to decrease the focus of minipulations and
arithmatic drill not do away with(see above)

I believe that the best quantitative
>and qualitative research in mathematics education shows that procedural
>and conceptual knowledge develop together, and that people (in general)
>need algorithmic experience in order to develop numerical understanding.



Your talking about over a hundred years(the last few decades of declining
effectiveness) compared with less then 10 years of "standards" focus.
hmmmm. How about giving it a chance? You might be surprised.



Remember: 1) we didn't grow up depending on calculators,

Why do people always say if it is good enough for us it is good enough for
you? Has the calculator been around forever(maybe 20+ years). Who is to
say that if it were around 20 years before you came along you wouldn't have
a different oppinion? Just because you were not dependent on a calculator
when you grew up does that mean the rest of the population wasn't? I just
don't see this as a relavent point for students today!!



2) our
>educational system is highly regarded around the world,

Uhhhh. How long ago was this? When you were going to school? Is it really
still high regarded? Maybe I read different news papers then you do?


3) and we have
>produced a highly creative and productive society with it.


What percent of our society would fit this? 10%? 20%? Is it really
highly productive? I don't know.



If there
>are voices that caution us not to throw the baby out with the bath waters
>of reform, there may be good reasons for it.



Are we saying to do away with other methods? I think it is to de-imphasise
not get rid of. If you read the standards you can see that clearly stated.

scott
















Scott Powell
University of Hawaii
University Labratory School
1776 University Ave.
Honolulu, Hi. 96822
powell@math.ed.hawaii.edu





















Date Subject Author
5/12/95
Read Graphing Calculators
ChuYing Singletary
5/12/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Ben Sultenfuss
5/12/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Joan Reinthaler
5/12/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Jerome Albani
5/14/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Wayne Murrah
5/16/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Eileen Abrahamson
5/16/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Steve Means
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Sam Evers
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Chi-Tien Hsu
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Richard W. Wilson
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Bill Juraschek
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Richard W. Wilson
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Richard W. Wilson
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Chi-Tien Hsu
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
W Gary Martin
10/26/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Chi-Tien Hsu
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
W Gary Martin
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Jack Roach
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
W Gary Martin
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Chi-Tien Hsu
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Richard W. Wilson
10/28/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Arthur Howard
10/29/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Richard W. Wilson
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
David Scott Powell
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
David Scott Powell
10/27/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
David Scott Powell
10/29/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Francis Fennell
10/29/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Richard W. Wilson
10/28/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Rebecca Corwin
10/28/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Chi-Tien Hsu
10/28/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Rebecca Corwin
10/29/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
roitman@oberon.math.ukans.edu
10/30/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Lou Talman
10/30/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
W Gary Martin
10/30/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Michael Paul Goldenberg
10/30/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Tom Johnson
10/31/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Francis Fennell
10/31/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Johnny Hamilton
10/31/95
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
roitman@oberon.math.ukans.edu
11/9/97
Read Re: Graphing Calculators
Rex Boggs

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.