Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Replies: 58   Last Post: Jun 24, 1995 3:44 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 DENNIS GELLER Posts: 16 Registered: 12/6/04
Posted: Jun 15, 1995 1:38 PM

>Does this mean that the student must be able to find the sine of 30
>degrees without anything but pencil and paper before being allowed to
>use a technical aid (even a table)?

My daughter came to me with help on trig (she's in IMP) and I was unpleasantly
surprised to find thet they didn't have any trig tables. In working with her
on some problems I used tables, and let her verify with the calculator.

I DO believe that there is more learning with use of tables than with the
calculator, because she got to see the numbers in the context of other sines.
How else does she get reinforcement on what reasonable values for the sine of
a particular angle are. or begin to understand that small changes in angle lead
to small (but not proportionate) changes in sine? I'm sure that the teacher
covered or will cover all of this, and will do it well, but since my daughter
didn't grasp that topic too well, the reinforcement was useful.

Similarly, I would really like to make her plot (by hand, on graph paper) a few
sine curves. I don't believe that seeing the curves on a graphing calculator
can possibly teach as well as doing them by hand, and having to THINK about
what value to plot at 45 degrees, or where the curve of sin 2x touches the x
axis.

Sure, use the calculators for calculating, but I think only very few students
are likely to sit with them and experiment for long enough to gain the same
understanding that's to be had from even a small visit to the trig tables.

Dennis Geller

Date Subject Author
6/11/95 Thomas J. Delaney
6/11/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/13/95 David E. Thomas
6/13/95 Ed Wall
6/13/95 Karen Dee Michalowicz
6/14/95 David E. Thomas
6/13/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/14/95 Michael Paul Goldenberg
6/14/95 Arthur Howard
6/14/95 Linda Dodge (Frontier RSH)
6/14/95 David Scott Powell
6/14/95 David Scott Powell
6/14/95 David Scott Powell
6/14/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/14/95 Arthur Howard
6/15/95 Chi-Tien Hsu
6/15/95 Arthur Howard
6/15/95 Chi-Tien Hsu
6/14/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/14/95 DanH150093@aol.com
6/14/95 Michael South
6/14/95 DanH150093@aol.com
6/14/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/14/95 Michael Paul Goldenberg
6/15/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/15/95 Lou Talman
6/15/95 DENNIS GELLER
6/15/95 DanH150093@aol.com
6/15/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/15/95 DoctorCHEK@aol.com
6/16/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/16/95 Arthur Howard
6/16/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/16/95 Lou Talman
6/16/95 DanH150093@aol.com
6/17/95 Arthur Howard
6/17/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/17/95 Arthur Howard
6/18/95 ciclista@host.yab.com
6/19/95 Arthur Howard
6/19/95 ciclista@host.yab.com
6/20/95 Arthur Howard
6/22/95 ciclista@host.yab.com
6/23/95 Chi-Tien Hsu
6/23/95 ciclista@host.yab.com
6/23/95 Arthur Howard
6/19/95 ciclista@host.yab.com
6/17/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/17/95 Arthur Howard
6/17/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/18/95 Mark Priniski
6/19/95 DENNIS GELLER
6/19/95 Sandra Pratt
6/22/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/23/95 Arthur Howard
6/22/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/24/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/24/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com
6/24/95 COVbECKERS@aol.com