The Math Forum

Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Math Forum » Discussions » Policy and News » mathed-news

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: New Math Failing - Des Moines, IA
Replies: 0  

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List  
Jerry P. Becker

Posts: 16,576
Registered: 12/3/04
New Math Failing - Des Moines, IA
Posted: Dec 22, 1999 5:08 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

From Des Moines Register, Des Moines, IA, December 12, 1999


Critics give new math failing score

By Kathy A. Bolten

Full Text:

Five years ago, Des Moines school officials replaced traditional elementary
math textbooks with colorful new books rich in literature, geographical
references and hands-on activities.

The new curriculum was billed as math students' salvation. Youngsters would
leave elementary school with a better understanding of mathematical
concepts. They would be better prepared for middle- school math. Test
scores would soar.

That hasn't happened, critics say.

Many Des Moines elementary students are being short-changed when it comes
to math, said Des Moines board member Marc Ward. Students are leaving
elementary school without mastering basic concepts, such as multiplication
and division. Less than half have a strong enough math background to pass
algebra, fast becoming a required course in high schools nationwide.

"There are basic skills students need to have in the early grades, and they
are not getting it with the curriculum we now have," Ward said.

Parent Kimberly Baudino said Des Moines' students lack a strong math

"This new book is all pictures and talks a lot about working together as a
group," said Baudino. "It's ridiculous that these kids are not learning the
math skills they need to have."

Board President Harold Sandahl and Ward last week pushed school
administrators to make algebra a required high school course next fall.
Administrators balked, saying if algebra were required, many students would
fail. Currently, about 70 percent of Des Moines' high schoolers take
algebra; 40 percent fail, board members were told.

"We are working on the elementary math curriculum so that in three years we
will have a math curriculum in place so that not only will students be
required to take algebra but they will take it and be successful," Jerry
Wadden, Des Moines' chief academic officer, told the board. "We need to
build the curriculum below" algebra.

Added Superintendent Eric Witherspoon: "That's what we don't have now."

Witherspoon and Wadden backed away from their comments about the elementary
math curriculum in a subsequent interview. Wadden said it hadn't yet been
determined whether the third-through fifth-grade math curriculum would be
revamped. A committee of elementary math teachers is studying the issue, he
said. A decision is expected in the spring.

Avon Crawford, who teaches at Brook-Lucas Elementary School, strongly
supports the elementary math textbook and curriculum. She said her students
are "much better problem-solvers than they ever have been before. We don't
have pages and pages of problems to do."

Board member Nadine Hogate said it may be more practical for the district
to take a middle-of-the-road approach to elementary math. "Hands-on stuff
is OK, but sometimes it's essential to learn things by rote, too."

Waiting Period

Regardless of what happens to the elementary math curriculum, Wadden and
Witherspoon said it would be three years before they recommended requiring
algebra in high school.

Sandahl and Ward aren't content to wait. They want the algebra requirement
next fall. Students who struggle could get extra help, they said.

Both also want the "new" elementary math textbooks replaced with more
traditional texts. They believe the textbook and the hands-on teaching
style it emphasizes are why students struggle in math.

The book, published by Houghton Mifflin, encourages the use of calculators
and teaches students to solve problems through estimations and hands-on
work. The book has few "drill and skill" problems, Sandahl said. Instead,
there are sections such as "Rain Forest Math," which asks students to
figure how many acres of a rain forest get cleared away each hour.

The textbook also jumps from one concept to another, Sandahl and other
critics say. In the first 100 pages of the fourth-grade book, for example,
students learn how to calculate volume, estimate and round numbers, figure
out concepts of time, and measure items.

Remedial Lessons

When the new math books were purchased five years ago for $326,000, Sandahl
said, board members were told there would be so much improvement in
students' math abilities that fewer remedial classes would be needed at the
middle schools. Instead, the past two years have seen an increase in
remedial lessons, including after- school tutoring at each middle school
and an expansion of middle- school summer school.

Results of the standardized tests called Iowa Tests of Basic Skills show no
growth in math skills. They also show no significant declines.

A district report nearly two years ago showed nearly half of Des Moines'
elementary schools failed to meet the district goal of having 70 percent of
students earn at least a "C" on district tests.

"We're off-track in math and we need to fix it," Sandahl said.

Wadden said it is unfair to say that faulty elementary math lessons are the
reason some middle-school students need remedial help. "We've always had
remediation and we always will," he said. "Remedial math and the
after-school tutoring was not brought about because of this math series."

A Lot of Reading

Marion Eppright, a vice principal at Edmunds Academy of Fine Arts, said the
textbook has little emphasis on basic skills. Plus, "there's a lot of
reading involved in it," said Eppright, who taught math until this school
year and frequently used the district's old textbook. "Many students have
reading problems. That makes it difficult to understand the (math) problem."

Pleasant Hill Elementary School fifth-grade teacher Sue Stanley also is
frustrated by the new book. "It's a pretty book with pretty pictures, but
it doesn't teach math."

Newton school officials had similar concerns about the textbook, which it
purchased about six years ago. Some teachers were concerned that students
weren't learning basic math facts, said Tom Hoover, Newton's director of

The district recently bought supplemental materials from the publisher that
reinforced basic math facts, Hoover said.

The textbook was developed in the early 1990s and "isn't dissimilar to
other programs at that time," said Margaret Sherry, director of Houghton
Mifflin's media relations. Now "we're seeing a shift in preferences."

The company's new math series has "more problems and less text. It provides
a more balanced math program," Sherry said.
Reporter Kathy A. Bolten can be reached at (515) 284-8283 or
Illustration: Kelly Gipple, center, works with Kathy Leothi, left, and
Michelle Rockwell on math skills at Weeks Middle School in Des Moines.
Caption: DOUG WELLS/The Register
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or
distribution is prohibited without permission.

Jerry P. Becker
Dept. of Curriculum & Instruction
Southern Illinois University
Carbondale, IL 62901-4610 USA
Fax: (618) 453-4244
Phone: (618) 453-4241 (office)
(618) 457-8903 (home)


Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2018. All Rights Reserved.