The Math Forum

Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Math Forum » Discussions » Policy and News » mathed-news

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Indiana: Standards are throw-back to yesteryear
Replies: 0  

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List  
Jerry P. Becker

Posts: 16,576
Registered: 12/3/04
Indiana: Standards are throw-back to yesteryear
Posted: Jul 10, 2000 10:30 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply
att1.html (8.1 K)

From the Vincennes (Indiana) Sun-Commercial, Sunday, June 25, 2000, p. B2.

Educators: Proposed math standards a throw-back to yesteryear

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) -- Some educators claim proposed math standards for
Indiana's schools are a throw-back to yesteryear, not the rigorous
updated guidelines as state officials contend.

"One of my colleagues said when he read this draft that he felt like
getting a crew cut because he felt like he was reading a document in
the '50s," said William Frascella, director of the Indiana
University Center for Math Education.

Stan Jones, the state's higher education commissioner, disputes such
criticism, including claims the standards were drawn up with little
input from educators in the field.

"This could not have been a more open process," said Jones, who has
helped guide the Education Roundtable, a statutory advisory group on
education policy.

"The state Department of Education and the Higher Education
Commission have had a number of teachers assisting us in the
process," he said. "We had invited that particular group (to help) on
several occasions, but they chose not to. They would rather be mad."

The Roundtable, a group of educators, business leaders, parents and
others, is expected to recommend next month that the proposed math
standards be adopted by the State Board of Education.

The state is trying to make education standards more challenging as
well as clear and concise. The Roundtable gave its blessing to new
standards in language arts last Monday and the Board of Education
adopted them.

A report issued early this year by Achieve Inc., a
Massachusetts-based organization created by governors and business
leaders to promote better standards, was in part highly critical of
Indiana's current standards.

Among other things, it said guidelines for what students should learn
at each grade level were not as challenging as in some other states
and are missing some key content.

Jones said the state has been working to correct those problems in
the new standards.

"They are going to be a lot more rigorous, have a lot more content
and most importantly be clearer and easier for teachers and parents
to know what is expected (of students)," Jones said.

For example, the proposed standards ask that students in second grade
be able to count by ones, twos, fives and 10s to 100. Seventh-graders
should be able to understand square roots and convert between
fractions and decimals.

But Frascella said the proposed standards are too simplistic, do not
take into account highly respected research on teaching math, and do
not emphasize technology, such as using computers and software in
applying math skills.

He sent the Roundtable letters and e-mails from others who share some
of his concerns, including Frank Lester, a math professor at IU;
Robert Trammel, math curriculum coordinator for Fort Wayne Community
Schools and Jim Hersberger, a math professor at Indiana University,
Fort Wayne.

Frascella said the state's current standards are more closely aligned
with national standards and the proposed changes could cost the
state. That's because the federal government and private groups often
align grant requirements with widely accepted national standards.

"In an age where the support of both business and federal funding is
critical to the improvement of education, I am especially alarmed
that anything like the current draft will become official state
policy," Frascella said in his letter.

The group also believes the standards were initially drafted with
little input from math teachers and professors. When those educators
were asked to review them this past spring, they were given too
little time and too little influence, they say.

Lester said he, Trammel and Frascella met with the Department of
Education officials and voiced their concerns.

"We were told they were only going to make cosmetic changes," Lester
said. He said because of that, he declined any further role in
reviewing the proposed standards.

Dorothy Winchester, director of the program development for the
Department of 'Education, said the agency posted the proposed
standards on the Internet March 15 and has been taking suggestions
about them since then even though the formal cut-off date for public
comment was May 15.

She also said they were sent to the Indiana Council of Teachers of
Mathematics and several other professional associations for review,
and post cards were sent to every principal in the state asking to
have their teachers provide feedback.

"We have collected comments of all kinds and have put together an
editing task-force and curriculum coordinator to go through every
single comment, and as best we could, adjust the standards based on
the feedback," Winchester said.

She said she met with the group of concerned educators and told them
their advice would be valued, but two days later, she received an
e-mail "telling me the group would not participate."

"My personal opinion is it's disengenuous for a group to say it was
not included, that I did not knock at their door," she said. "It's
unfortunate because in this whole process we have been working
extremely hard to reach consensus."

Marvin Bailey, president of the Corporation of Education Technology,
a public-private organization that promotes technology in school
curriculum, said an initial version of the standards did not include
enough technology use.

But he said he had a group of 10 people work for two weeks making
suggested revisions to the standards, and has since been told that
many of them are included in the draft proposal.

"We think we upgraded them considerably and feel pretty good about
what is in there, he said.

Frascella said he hopes the Roundtable will hold public hearings on
the standards before recommending their adoption to the Board of

Larry Grau, Gov. Frank O'Bannon's executive assistant on education,
said officials again will ask the educators to "come personally and
speak to the Roundtable" and submit more specific comments about the

"I don't know how much more we could have done to make this a
wide-open process," he said.

Jerry P. Becker
Dept. of Curriculum & Instruction
Southern Illinois University
Carbondale, IL 62901-4610 USA
Fax: (618) 453-4244
Phone: (618) 453-4241 (office)
(618) 457-8903 (home)


Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2018. All Rights Reserved.