Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: subtraction
Replies: 6   Last Post: Jul 22, 2001 8:49 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Judy Ann Brown Posts: 192 Registered: 12/3/04
subtraction
Posted: Mar 21, 2001 6:15 PM

Hi

I have a question. How do you teach subtraction? No, that's not
really my question. What I really want to know is how you feel about
the wording that students use to express subtraction.

As I grade "Mr. Pearson's Statistics Lesson" in the Middle School PoW,
I find that many students are correctly finding the range using
subtraction. However they are having a terrible time trying to tell me
what they are doing.

Some of the things I've seen are:

"i found the range which is the difference between the least and the
greatest numbers in a set. I subtracted 99 from 45 and got 54."

"The way I got the range of the test scores was by subtracting the
highest score which was 99 by the lowest score which was 45 and I got
54 as the range. 99-45=54"

"i took 99 witch was the highest socre and subtracted it by 45 witch
was the lowest socre, and i got 54."

"to find the range i must minus the hightest and lowest extremes.
99-45 = 54"

I don't recall ever learning to subtract "by" a number. Is that
terminology something I missed?

I'm not denying credit if they subtract "by," in fact I'm seeing it so
much that I hardly notice it any more. ;-) Is it something you get
used to, like not capitalizing the word "I"?

We really have to pick and choose our battles, right?

I am denying credit and asking for revisions if students tell me that
45-99 is 54. Please say it isn't so!

:-)
Judy

Date Subject Author
3/21/01 Judy Ann Brown
3/22/01 Jere Carman
3/22/01 Judy Ann Brown
3/22/01 Pat Hagan
6/4/01 Natlison
6/7/01 darren
7/22/01 faisalshah