After scoring student replies with our rubric for a few months, we felt that a reorganization was in order. We haven't really changed the rubric, we've simply changed the order in which it's presented. The scores included in the replies that students receive now look like this:
Problem Solving Interpretation: [level] Strategy: [level] Accuracy: [level]
Communication Completeness: [level] Clarity: [level] Reflection: [level]
This reorganization better reflects the order in which we find actually score the submissions.
If you have any questions or comments about our rubric or the replies that your students have been receiving, feel free to post them to this list or to write to me directly.
-- Annie Fetter is responsible for the Geometry and Algebra PoWs. She writes many of the problems, does a lot of mentoring, and is currently training volunteer mentors who will be helping us to respond to students more quickly in all of the services.