Prove the Commutative Law
Date: 4/1/96 at 5:23:36 From: Anonymous Subject: The Commutative Law Hi Dr. Math! I'm a pupil in the 10th grade here in Israel. I have a question that may sound very silly: Can anyone PROVE the Commutative law? Is a * b = b * a ? It sounds silly, but a * b means a TIMES b, which is b+b+b... a times, and b * a means a+a+a... b times. How can you prove it's the same result? I have no clue how even to start solving this question. It seems so obvious, but so difficult to solve. Hope you can help me, Lior Barenboim
Date: 5/30/96 at 11:39:26 From: Doctor Alain Subject: Re: The Commutative Law Your question is not silly at all. Many people know things that they can't prove, and this sometimes leads to many people "knowing" things which are false. Commutativity of multiplication can be proved by using the fact that a * b is the area of a rectangle whose sides are of length a and b. 3 * 4 = 12 So 3 rows of 4 Xs have 12 Xs. But obviously there is the same number of Xs in 4 columns of 3 Xs, so 4 * 3 = 12 also. X X X X X X X X X X X X So a * b is equal to the number of Xs in "a" rows containing "b" Xs each. It's also equal to the number of Xs in "b" columns containing "a" Xs each. -Doctor Alain, The Math Forum
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.