The Math Forum

Ask Dr. Math - Questions and Answers from our Archives
Associated Topics || Dr. Math Home || Search Dr. Math

Vector Calculus

Date: 02/10/99 at 07:42:48
From: D. Denduyver
Subject: Vector Calculus

Can you help me and my son prove the following identity:

a . (grad(a . v) - curl (v x a)) = div v,

where a = constant unit vector
      . = scalar product
      x = vector product
      v = vector

We've found that:

 a . curl (v x a) = a .(( a . V) v - a (V . v)) = a. (a . V)v - V . v

but a . (grad(a . v)) - a . (a . V)v + V . v is not equal to V . v

with V = del or nabla operator.

Can you also give us a title of a textbook where we can find the proof 
of de (p,r) equation of an ellipse with (p, r) = pedal coordinates?

Thank you very much,

Dany Denduyver

Date: 02/10/99 at 09:51:12
From: Doctor Mitteldorf
Subject: Re: Vector Calculus

My general approach for vector calculus identities is to write them 
out as coordinates, using the Einstein summation convention. So A.B 
becomes AiBi and V x F becomes EijkVjFk. For the cross product, use 
epsilon-ijk, which I've written Eijk. 

E123 = E312 = E231 = 1 and E321 = E213 = E132 = -1, and all their 
combinations, like E112 and E333, are zero.

The particular identity you're working with is really much easier than 
it looks, because a is a unit vector.  You can take a to be the unit 
vector in the 3 direction, which I'll call z, without loss of 

a.v = v3, and (a.V) is just V3 (Notation:  I'm using V for del and V3 
means "del sub 3", the derivative in the z direction.)
So a . grad(a . v) = V3(v3), i.e., the derivative in the z direction 
of the z component of v.

Now for the second term: (v x a) has a component in the 1 direction 
equal to v2, and its component in the 2 direction is -v1.

We need the 3 component of the curl of this (because we're taking the 
dot product of the curl with a). This is V1 (v x a)2 - V2 (vxa)1, or, 
using the above, -V1(v1) - V2(v2).

So, collecting all terms, we have V3(v3) + V1(v1) + V2(v2), which is 
indeed the divergence of v. 

I learned vector calculus years ago from E. M. Purcell, _Electricity 
and Magnetism_, Vol. II of the Berkeley Physics Course.

I'm not familiar with pedal coordinates, so I'm leaving this message 
up where another doctor might be able to direct you to an appropriate 

- Doctor Mitteldorf, The Math Forum   

Date: 02/10/99 at 18:29:22
From: Doctor Anthony
Subject: Re: Vector Calculus

I believe you have had a reply on the first question so will confine 
my remarks to the pedal equation of the ellipse.

If phi = angle between the tangent at a point on the curve and the 
radius vector to that point (polar coordinates) then a simple diagram 

  tan(phi) = r.d(theta)/dr

  sin(phi) = r.d(theta)/ds

  cos(phi) = dr/ds

If p = perpendicular from the origin to the tangent then

     p = r.sin(phi)

To express p in terms of r we can write

  1/p^2 = 1/r^2 cosec^2(phi) = (1/r^2)[1 + cot^2(phi)]

        = (1/r^2)[1 + (1/r^2)(dr/d(theta))^2]

  1/p^2 = 1/r^2 + (1/r^2)[dr/d(theta)]^2   .........(1)

By eliminating theta between this equation and the polar equation of 
the curve we get the equation between p and r, the pedal equation.

Example: Consider the conic with the given equation.

For the curve  2a/r = 1 - cos(theta)  find the (p,r) equation.

Differentiating  -2a/r^2 [dr/d(theta)] = sin(theta)

     So,  r.d(theta)/dr = -2a/(r.sin(theta))  
and from eqn. of curve, 
                         = -(1 - cos(theta))/sin(theta)
and so, 
tan(phi) = -2sin^(theta/2)/[2sin(theta/2).cos(theta/2)]

tan(phi) = -tan(theta/2)  = tan(pi-theta/2)

and                   phi = pi - theta/2


p = r.sin(phi) 
  = r.sin(theta/2)

and from eqn. of curve

  =  2a.sin(theta/2)/[1-cos(theta)]

  =  2a.sin(theta/2)/[2.sin^2(theta/2)]

  =  a/sin(theta/2)

  =  a.cosec(theta/2)

      p^2 = a^2.cosec^2(theta/2)  ..............(2)


r = 2a/(1-cos(theta)) = a/sin^2(theta/2)

 therefore,   cosec^2(theta/2) = r/a

and from (2),     p^2 = a^2.r/a

                  p^2 = a.r        

which is the pedal equation of the conic.

- Doctor Anthony, The Math Forum   
Associated Topics:
High School Calculus

Search the Dr. Math Library:

Find items containing (put spaces between keywords):
Click only once for faster results:

[ Choose "whole words" when searching for a word like age.]

all keywords, in any order at least one, that exact phrase
parts of words whole words

Submit your own question to Dr. Math

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

Math Forum Home || Math Library || Quick Reference || Math Forum Search

Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.