The Moving Shadow
Date: 03/24/99 at 20:27:32 From: Isaac Subject: Related Rates of a Shadow's Movement I am not sure I did this problem right, because here the man walks towards the light source, whereas in other problems of this nature he usually walks away from the light. Please check to see whether I did it right. A man 6 feet tall walks at a rate of 5 feet per second toward a light that is 20 feet above the ground. a) At what rate is the tip of his shadow moving? b) At what rate is the length of his shadow changing? ^ |` 20 | ` v | 0 | /|\` | / \ ` ------------- dx ---- = 5feet/sec dt 20 y --- = ----- 6 y - x 20y - 20x = 6y 14y = 20x 20x y = ------ 14 10x y = ----- 7 dy 10 dx --- = ---------- dt 7 dt dy 10 50 -- = --- (5) = ---- ft/sec, since he is walking towards the light dt 7 7 50 then it is negative, - ---- ft/sec 7 a) -(50/7) ft/sec b) d(y-x) dy dx -(50) ------ = ---- - ---- = ----- - (5) = -(85/7) ft/sec dt dt dt 7
Date: 03/26/99 at 13:59:44 From: Doctor Luis Subject: Re: Related Rates of a Shadow's Movement Your reasoning for the first part was correct; however, you could have made dx/dt negative from the start. That is why the second part (b) is not correct. Here is a diagram: P |\ | \ | \ | \ | \ | \N | |\ | | \ | | \ |_____|___\ O M S According to the problem, OP is 20 ft, MN is 6 ft. The man, at M, is walking TOWARD the light source at O. If x is the distance OM, then dx/dt HAS to be negative because the x-values are decreasing. Now, if y is the distance OS, (where the tip of the shadow is at S), then, as you explained above, by similar triangles you have: OP OS ----- = ----- MN MS 20 y ---- = ------ 6 y - x and so you found y = (10/7)x Now if you just differentiate with respect to time, you get dy/dt = (10/7)dx/dt = (10/7)(-5) = -50/7 ft/s You can see that by making dx/dt negative from the start you avoid the complication of changing the sign of dy/dt in the middle of the problem. (That is why you did not get the last part.) Given that, we find how fast the length of the shadow is changing: d --- (y - x) = dy/dt - dx/dt = (-50/7) - (-5) = -15/7 ft/sec dt Notice that the term -dx/dt makes a positive contribution to the rate of change of the length of the shadow. This makes sense from a physical standpoint, because if the tip of the shadow were to be held still, the man, by walking away, would actually be increasing the length of the shadow (y-x would be increasing if y were constant). However, y is not constant, it is decreasing, and that's why it makes a negative contribution to the rate of change of the length of the shadow. My recommendation to you is that you choose a consistent set of directions from the start (for example in this problem we chose the direction of increasing x-values to the right) and then, based on that, give the time-derivatives the appropriate signs according to whether the values whose rate of change they represent are increasing or decreasing. If you do this from the beginning of the problem, you will not have to be changing the signs every time. What I am trying to say is you need to be consistent. - Doctor Luis, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.