Inscribing a Square in a Triangle
Date: 10/13/2000 at 01:15:32 From: Alexandra Subject: Geometry - Triangle How can you inscribe a square in a scalene triangle? I have no idea how to start.
Date: 10/13/2000 at 11:13:20 From: Doctor Rob Subject: Re: Geometry - Triangle Thanks for writing to Ask Dr. Math, Alexandra. Let the triangle be ABC, and let AB be the longest side. Then <A and <B are acute. We will construct a square one of whose sides lies along AB and whose other two corners lie on AC and BC. Pick a point D on AC, and drop a perpendicular from D to AB, meeting it at point E. Mark point F on AB (possibly extended) such that DE = DF, and D is between A and F. Erect a perpendicular to AB at F. On the same side of AB as D, mark point G such that FG = DE. Connect D and G, and you have a square DEFG. C _o _- \ _- \ _- \ _- \ _- \ _- G \ D _- o---------o _- | |\ _- | | \ _- | | \ _- | | \ B o--------------------o---------o----o A F E Now draw line AG. This is the locus of the upper left corner of all squares with a side along AB and upper right corner on AC. Let the point of intersection of AG and BC be H. Then H is the upper left corner of the inscribed square lying on BC. C _o _- \ _- \ _- \ H _- \ _o._ \ _- `-. G \ D _- `o---------o _- | `-. |\ _- | `-. | \ _- | `-| \ _- | |`-.\ B o--------------------o---------o----o A F E Drop a perpendicular from H to AB, meeting it at point I. Draw a line through H parallel to AB, and intersecting AC at K. K is the upper right corner of the inscribed square lying on AC. Drop a perpendicular from K to AB, meeting it at J. IJ is the side of the inscribed square lying along AB. Then HIJK is the required inscribed square. (Clearly HIJK is a rectangle. You can prove that HK = HI by using similar triangles and the fact that FG = DG, so HIJK is a square.) C _o _- \ _- \ _- \ H _- \ K _o._------------o _- | `-. G |\ D _- | `o-------+-o _- | | `-. | |\ _- | | `-.| | \ _- | | |-| \ _- | | | |`-.\ B o-------------o------o-------o-o----o A I F J E Why did we choose AB so that <A and <B were acute? - Doctor Rob, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Date: 10/13/2000 at 14:02:14 From: Doctor Floor Subject: Re: Geometry - Triangle Hi, Alexandra, I saw the beautiful answer that Dr. Rob has given, but since I took a different approach I thought you might like my reply as an addition. Let us consider ABC, angles A and B acute, with an inscribed square PQRS with side PQ on AB: C _o _- |\ _- | \ _- | \ S _- | \ R _o---------+----o _- | | |\ _- | | | \ _- | | | \ _- | | | \ _- | | | \ _- | | | \ A o-------------o---------o----o------o B P D Q CD is the perpendicular altitude from C. For the length let CD = h. Let SC = q*AC, so that S divides AC in the ratio CS:SA = q : 1-q. Since SR is parallel to AB, we know that ABC and SRC are similar. So we have the equal ratios CS:CA = CR:CB = SR:AB. We conclude SR = q*AB. On the other hand CD is parallel to SP, so we have similar triangles ADC and APS. And from AS = (1-q)*AC we find in the same way as above that SP = (1-q)*CD = (1-q)*h. Of course in a square SR = SP, or q*AB=(1-q)*h q*AB = h - q*h q*(AB+h) = h q = h/(AB+h) and thus 1-q = (AB+h)/(AB+h) - h/(AB+h) = AB/(AB+h) But that gives us that CS:SA = q:1-q = h:AB, and S divides AC in the ratio of the altitude CD and the side AB. That gives a simple construction: C _o _- |\`-. _- | \ `-. _- | \ `-. S _- | \ R `-. _o---------+----o `-. _- |`-. | |\ `-. _- | `-. | | \ `-. _- | `-.| | \ `-. _- | |-. | \ `-. _- | | `-| \ `-. _- | | |`-._ \ `-._ A o-------------o---------o----o------o------------------------o P D Q B X Let X be on AB extended, so that BX = CD. Then let S be the point where the parallel to XC through B meets AC. Then S divides AC in the same ratio as B divides AX, and thus in the desired AB:h. The rest of the construction is straightforward. I hope you liked this addition. If you have more questions, just write back. Best regards, - Doctor Floor, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Date: 10/13/2000 at 18:22:48 From: Alexandra Subject: Re: Geometry - Triangle Thank you for your reply. I had trouble with the proof, not realizing which triangles we are proving similar. I ended up proving two pairs of similar triangles. One side of the smaller square is on one triangle in each pair, and one side of the inscribed square is on the other triangle in each pair. I think that you must have <A and <C acute because otherwise the perpendicular drawn to AC will fall outside the triangle and not allow you to find the locus which locates the top left-hand point of the inscribed square. Thank you for your help, Alexandra
Date: 10/16/2000 at 09:26:03 From: Doctor Rob Subject: Re: Geometry - Triangle Thanks for writing back. Your similar triangle pairs were just the ones of which I was thinking. Yes, your reason for <A and <C acute is correct. Good work! Obviously you are grasping the subject pretty well. - Doctor Rob, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.