Logic - Liars & Truthtellers (What Question Does She Ask?)
Date: 12 Mar 1995 00:21:59 -0500 From: Anonymous Subject: Another Math Question A logician vacationing in the South Seas finds herself on an island inhabited by the two proverbial tribes of liars and truth-tellers. The members of one tribe always tell the truth, and the members of the other always lie. She comes to a fork in the road and has to ask a native bystander which path she should take to reach a village. She has no way of telling whether the native is a liar or a truth-teller. To further complicate matters, the natives of the island will only answer yes-or-no questions. The logician thinks a moment, then asks ONE question only. From the reply, she knows which road to take. What question does she ask? Thanks a whole lot!
Date: 12 Mar 1995 12:44:31 -0500 From: Dr. Ethan Subject: Re: Another Math Question Hello! The key here is to ensure that you phrase the question so that you will get the same answer from both parties. To do this, you need to ask a question that will involve both of their opinions. Think about this question: Is water wet? The liar will say no, the truth teller yes. But what if I ask this question: "If I were to ask a member of the tribe that you don't belong to 'Is water wet?' what would he say?" Well, the truth teller would answer truthfully that the liars would lie and say no. The liar would lie and say that the truth tellers would say no. So you see with this new way that we have phrased the question, we have guaranteed a falsehood, so the opposite must be true. Think how you might phrase a question related to your problem in a similar way. Good Luck. [See also the Classic Problem "Liars and Truthtellers" in the Dr. Math FAQ: http://mathforum.org/dr.math/faq/faq.liar.html .] Ethan, Doctor On Call
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.