Odds and Probability (A Heated Argument)
Date: 01/24/2001 at 11:05:08 From: mike Subject: Odds and Probability (A Heated Argument) I hope you can help me and explain something to me as simply as you possibly can. My friend and I are having a raffle. It has 40 prizes in it. If your name is drawn you go up and spin a wheel. You win the prize that the spot on the wheel lands on. If you win, your raffle ticket goes back into the hat and you are eligable to win again. There is not a limit on how many times you can win. My partner wants to have 8 spots on the wheel. He wants to start out with cheaper prizes and gradually move up to the more expensive prizes. This is where we disagree. I say that we should have all 40 spots(prizes) on the wheel showing at all times, and if you hit a spot that has already won, you just spin again. This way everybody who has been lucky enough to have their raffle ticket drawn has a chance to win the big prizes. My partner says that everybody does have a chance to win the big prizes because their raffle tickets go back into the hat. He is basically saying that on each individual drawing you have a 1/150 chance in winning. I say that is true on each individual drawing, but you cannot look at it that way. Your chances of winning 2 or more times are more against you then you winning on any single drawing, and therefore if you win on the first drawing, you should be eligible for all prizes because it is greatly against you that you will win again. He says no, you still have a 1/150 chance, just like everybody else, on every drawing.
Date: 01/24/2001 at 11:53:46 From: Doctor Schwa Subject: Re: Odds and Probability (A Heated Argument) Hi Mike, Your friend is right. As long as the tickets go back in the hat after they're drawn, and each of the 40 prizes is awarded exactly once to somebody, your chances of winning the big prize are the same regardless of whether your ticket has already been drawn. The advantage of the "all on the wheel" system is that nobody knows when the big prize is going to come, so they pay attention. On the other hand, if the first person to spin gets the big prize, then everyone else will be less interested the rest of the time. The advantage of the "put the big prizes on last" system is that there's the suspense waiting for the end... but the disadvantage is that people might not pay much attention at the beginning when only the little prizes are up for grabs. - Doctor Schwa, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.