The Math Forum

Ask Dr. Math - Questions and Answers from our Archives
Associated Topics || Dr. Math Home || Search Dr. Math

Area vs. Perimeter of Rectangles

Date: 03/19/2000 at 16:19:30
From: Melissa
Subject: Perimeter and area

I don't understand how two rectangles with exactly the same perimeter 
can enclose different areas. Can you explain that to me?

Thank you,

Date: 03/19/2000 at 23:15:36
From: Doctor Peterson
Subject: Re: Perimeter and area

Hi, Melissa.

I can start by convincing you that it's really true. A mathematician 
often looks at a question like this by thinking about the extreme 
cases, to get a feel for how far things can go. So let's think about 
extreme rectangles.

Suppose you make a loop of string, say 24 inches long, and try to make 
a rectangle of it, by putting four fingers into the loop and moving 
them around. What's the widest rectangle you can make? Pull your 
fingers as far as they can go, and you'll have something like this:

If you imagine your fingers having no width, you can see that the 
widest rectangle possible would have zero height (or as little as you 
are willing to have and still call it a rectangle) and width 12 
inches. Its area will be zero.

At the other extreme, of course, you can stretch your rectangle 
vertically so that it is 12 inches high with no width, and again has 
zero area. Yet you know that in between you do have a positive area, 
and in fact it will turn out that a square (with the width and height 
the same) will have the greatest area you can make.

So how can area change when the perimeter stays the same?

Here's one way to look at it, suggested by a problem someone sent in 
recently. Let's reverse the question and try to build a rectangle out 
of 12 one-inch squares (a fixed area) and see why we won't always get 
the same perimeter. The 12 squares will have a total perimeter of 48 
inches (4 inches each). If I line up the squares in a row, only two or 
three sides of each square will be part of the perimeter, while the 
others will be shared with neighbors:
     _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Each of the 11 "interior edges" between two squares takes away two 
inches from the perimeter (one side of each square), so the perimeter 
of this rectangle will be 48 - 22 = 26. Since the height is 1 and the 
width is 12, that's right: 1 + 12 + 1 + 12 = 26.

Now let's stack the squares closer together, in two rows of 6:
     _ _ _ _ _ _

Now there are 16 interior edges, because more of the squares are 
touching, so we subtract not 22 but 32 inches from the perimeter, 
which is now 48 - 32 = 16. Yes, this is 2 + 6 + 2 + 6.

Now let's lump them even closer together (more squarish), as a 3 x 4 
     _ _ _ _

Now there are 17 interior edges, so the perimeter is 48 - 34 = 14 
inches, which is equal to 3 + 4 + 3 + 4.

Do you see what's happening? The more squarish the rectangle is, the 
more edges the squares share, and the less they contribute to the 
perimeter, so the less the perimeter will be.

The same sort of thing happens with three-dimensional shapes, and this 
effect is important in such questions as how your body dissipates 
heat: if we picture our squares as cells, then a flat shape will let 
each cell be close to the surface and cool itself off, while a 
roundish shape will force more cells into the interior, where they 
won't be part of the surface, and also won't lose heat easily. Lumpy 
things have less "outside" for the same amount of "inside." (That's 
why elephants have thin ears, to radiate more heat, and why cactuses 
have thick stems, to retain more moisture.)

So the basic answer to your question is that area measures the 
"inside" of a shape and perimeter measures the "outside," and by 
changing the shape we can move outside parts to the inside without 
changing the outside. Or, if we keep the perimeter the same as you 
originally asked, we can keep the same "outside" but pack more 
"inside" into it, which will puff it up.

Thanks for the question - it's fun to think about this sort of thing!

- Doctor Peterson, The Math Forum   
Associated Topics:
Elementary Geometry
Elementary Triangles and Other Polygons
Elementary Two-Dimensional Geometry
Middle School Geometry
Middle School Triangles and Other Polygons
Middle School Two-Dimensional Geometry

Search the Dr. Math Library:

Find items containing (put spaces between keywords):
Click only once for faster results:

[ Choose "whole words" when searching for a word like age.]

all keywords, in any order at least one, that exact phrase
parts of words whole words

Submit your own question to Dr. Math

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

Math Forum Home || Math Library || Quick Reference || Math Forum Search

Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.