Cylinder Height, Area, Volume
Date: 04/07/2003 at 12:22:21 From: James Boulter Subject: Cylinder Height Dear Sirs, I have recently been working on an investigation into cylinders and how their volume is affected by their dimensions. The cylinder is open-ended and is formed by rolling up a piece of card whose height is x and with a fixed area A. The formula for the volume given the area of card and height of card is A^2/(4*PI*x). Supposing the area is 1200cm^2 and the height 20cm, the volume would therefore be 5730 cm^3. What is confusing is that if you keep on making the height smaller and smaller (i.e. the radius of the top becomes larger and larger), the volume keeps on going up and up. I have tried the formula for such low height values as 10^-6, and the volume gets higher and higher. Surely this defies physics? If the height is as small as physically possible (i.e. one atom thick), the volume would be huge. But I don't understand this because the cylinder wouldn't actually be able to hold anything. Perhaps you could explain why the volume gets larger and larger and tell me where I may be going wrong.
Date: 04/07/2003 at 23:38:33 From: Doctor Ian Subject: Re: Cylinder Height Hi James, I suppose the place to start might be by examining the formula you're using. If the card has height x, and area A, then its width is w = A/x But the width of the card is the circumference of the cylinder. If the radius of the cylinder is r, then w = 2 pi r A/x = 2 pi r A/(2 pi x) = r The volume of the cylinder will be volume = pi r^2 x = pi [A/(2 pi x)]^2 x pi A^2 x = ---------- 4 pi^2 x^2 A^2 = ------ 4 pi x Which is what you have. Good! Now look at the equation and think about what it _means_. Since A is fixed, the only thing we can vary is x, the height of the cylinder. And where is x? In the denominator. So if we make x greater, the value of the fraction - that is, the volume - has to get smaller. Conversely, if we make x smaller, the value of the fraction has to get bigger. So mathematically, this is what's going on. What about physically? Note that we often think of the 'volume' of something as the amount of stuff it can hold, but it's really a measure of how big something else needs to be to hold _it_ (i.e., how much space it takes up). After all, a solid lump of metal can't hold anything, but we would say that it has a volume, right? So just because something is too flat to hold anything doesn't mean it can't have a large volume. (If it helps, imagine buying a ream of paper. This definitely has a volume. Now spread the pieces out, one deep, over a gym floor. Now you have a lot of area, and hardly any height. But the volume of the paper is exactly the same.) Suppose we construct a particular cylinder with height x, and then slice it in half horizontally, so that we have two cylinders with height x/2. Now we put the two cylinders next to each other. So far, the volume of the two cylinders is the same as the volume of the cylinder that we started with, right? We have half the height, but twice the area, so it evens out. But now let's make a vertical cut in the side of the smaller cylinders, so we can roll them out and combine their circumferences to make one big circle. What will the area of the larger circle be? Well, if we start with two circles of radius r, the total area is area = 2 * (pi r^2) The circumference of each circle is circumference = 2 pi r So when we combine them, the circumference of the larger circle is circumference' = 2 * (2 pi r) = 4 pi r What is the area of this circle? It's area' = pi (2r)^2 = 4 pi r^2 which is twice the area we started with. So when we combine two circles in this way, we get a larger area. (You might have fun thinking about why this should be the case.) So here's a way to think about what's happening with the cylinder, as we shrink the height. We can shrink it by cutting the cylinder in two, then combining the circumferences of the two pieces. Each time we do this, we cut the height by a factor of two, but we increase the _area_ by more than a factor of two. That is, every time we shrink the cylinder, we more than gain in area what we give up in height. So the more you shrink the height, the more you increase the volume. Does this make sense? - Doctor Ian, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.