Standard Form of a Line (Ax + By = C)
Date: 10/07/2005 at 14:38:29 From: Kelly Subject: Ax + By = C form of a line In the standard form of a linear equation, Ax + By = C, what conditions do A, B, and C have to meet? Do you always have to have a positive integer for A? Do you have to have all the common factors of A, B, and C factored out? We know that A, B, and C should be integers according to our textbook definition. The textbook also gives all answers beginning with a positive A. Is this a standard way to write it, or just a preference of our book editors? We had a problem that worked out to .6x - y = 2.4. One student multiplied by 10 to get 6x - 10y = 24. Another used the fraction for .6 (3/5) and multiplied by 5 to get 3x - 5y = 12. I know they're equivalent equations, but are they both considered correct? Why doesn't our book say that you must have factored out the terms so you have the lowest values of A, B, and C? I hate to think I have to consider the infinite possibilities each time I check a paper.
Date: 10/07/2005 at 16:17:16 From: Doctor Rick Subject: Re: Ax + By = C form of a line Hi, Kelly. If your textbook says that A, B, and C must be integers, it is wrong! If that were so, the standard form Ax + By = C could not represent any line with irrational slope, or with an x- or y-intercept incommensurate with the slope. How would you put this equation into that form? y = pi*x - sqrt(2) The advantage of the standard form is that, unlike slope-intercept form for example, it can be used to represent *any* line. I wouldn't want to limit it by requiring A, B, and C to be integers! What I've said so far is math. The rest is pedagogy. Your last sentence says it all: "I hate to think I have to consider the infinite possibilities each time I check a paper." The convenience of the teacher (or perhaps another reader of a paper) is the only reason to put restrictions on A, B, and C. In practice most, if not all, of the problems presented to the students will involve rational numbers, so it will in fact be possible to make A, B, and C integers. I think it is quite reasonable to require this, and in addition that A be positive and that A, B, and C be relatively prime. This reduces the infinite possibilities to exactly one, and indeed makes your work easier. I'm all for that! I only ask that you make clear to the students that this is to help you, and not because math requires it. Maybe you could even drive this home to them by removing the restrictions for one assignment-- and having them grade one another's papers! - Doctor Rick, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.