Envelope
From Math Images
m 

Line 51:  Line 51:  
{{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  {{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  
  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure21Link=[[Image:Parabola1.pngcenterthumb250pxFigure 21]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:  +  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure21Link=[[Image:Parabola1.pngcenterthumb250pxFigure 21]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:Rightarrow2.pngcenter]]{{!}}{{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure22Link=[[Image:Parabola.gifcenterthumb300pxFigure 22 <br>Gif animation of Parabola envelope]]}} 
{{!}}}  {{!}}}  
Line 81:  Line 81:  
{{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  {{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  
  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure23Link=[[Image:Ellipse1.pngcenterthumb250pxFigure 23]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:  +  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure23Link=[[Image:Ellipse1.pngcenterthumb250pxFigure 23]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:Rightarrow2.pngcenter]]{{!}}{{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure24Link=[[Image:Ellipse2.gifcenterthumb300pxFigure 24<br>Gif animation of Ellipse envelope]]}} 
{{!}}}  {{!}}}  
Line 110:  Line 110:  
{{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  {{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  
  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure25Link=[[Image:Hyperbola1.pngcenterthumb250pxFigure 25]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:  +  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure25Link=[[Image:Hyperbola1.pngcenterthumb250pxFigure 25]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:Rightarrow2.pngcenter]]{{!}}{{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure26Link=[[Image:Hyperbola.gifcenterthumb300pxFigure 26 <br>Gif animation of Hyperbola envelope]]}} 
{{!}}}  {{!}}}  
Line 143:  Line 143:  
{{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  {{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  
  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure31Link=[[Image:Cardioid1ed1.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 31]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:  +  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure31Link=[[Image:Cardioid1ed1.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 31]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:Rightarrow2.pngcenter]]{{!}}{{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure32Link=[[Image:Cardioid.gifcenterthumb350pxFigure 32 <br>Gif animation of Cardioid envelope]]}} 
{{!}}}  {{!}}}  
Line 157:  Line 157:  
{{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  {{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  
  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure33Link=[[Image:Nephroid1ed1.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 33]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:  +  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure33Link=[[Image:Nephroid1ed1.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 33]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:Rightarrow2.pngcenter]]{{!}}{{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure34Link=[[Image:Nephroid2.gifcenterthumb350pxFigure 34 <br>Gif animation of Nephroid envelope]]}} 
{{!}}}  {{!}}}  
Line 169:  Line 169:  
{{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  {{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  
  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure35Link=[[Image:Lemniscate1ed1.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 35]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:  +  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure35Link=[[Image:Lemniscate1ed1.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 35]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:Rightarrow2.pngcenter]]{{!}}{{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure36Link=[[Image:Lemniscate.gifcenterthumb350pxFigure 36 <br>Gif animation of Lemniscate envelope]]}} 
{{!}}}  {{!}}}  
Line 182:  Line 182:  
{{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  {{{!}}border="0" cellpadding=5 cellspacing=5  
  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure37Link=[[Image:Lemniscate4.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 37<br> a variation of "lemniscate"]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:  +  {{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure37Link=[[Image:Lemniscate4.pngcenterthumb300pxFigure 37<br> a variation of "lemniscate"]]}}{{!}}{{!}}[[Image:Rightarrow2.pngcenter]]{{!}}{{!}}{{AnchorReference=Figure38Link=[[Image:bugsbunny.jpgcenterthumb300pxFigure 38 Aha! I have ears like a lemniscate!]]}} 
{{!}}}  {{!}}}  
Current revision
Blueaerialshell 

Blueaerialshell
 This is a beautiful blueaerialshell firework filling the sky. Each particle of the firework follows a parabolic trajectory, and together they sweep an area with the red curve as its boundary. This red boundary is then called the envelope of those parabolas. What's more, as we are going to see in the following sections, this envelope also turns out to be a parabola.
Contents 
Basic Description
In geometry, an envelope of a family of curves is the boundary of these curves' "sweeping area". In most cases, the envelope is tangent to each member of the family at some point.


Surprisingly, as shown in Figure 12, the area swept by a moving straight line does not necessarily have a straight boundary. In fact, its envelope is the firstquadrant portion of an astroid . One may notice the Astroid is always tangent to the ladder at some point during the sliding process, as stated in the definition of an envelope.
If we slide the ladder in the other three quadrants, we will get a complete starshaped envelope, as shown in Figure 13. In fact, the name astroid comes from the Greek word for "star".
For the math behind this envelope, please go to the More Mathematical Explanation section.
A gallery of beautiful envelopes
Envelopes of lines
As we have seen in the ladder example, a moving straight line can have a curve as its envelope. Here are more examples:


In Figure 21, line m, our sweeping line, is perpendicular to segment OA at its midpoint M. Point O is fixed in space.
If we slide point A along line l, line m will sweep out a Parabola, with point O as its focus and line l as its directrix.


Similar to what we did in Figure 21, our sweeping line is still the perpendicular bisector of segment AB. The only difference is that point A now slides on a circle, rather a straight line.
The result is an Ellipse with O and B as its foci, as shown in Figure 24.


Similar to what we did in the previous example, our sweeping line is still the perpendicular bisector of segment AB. The only difference is that point B is outside the circle.
The result is a hyperbola with O and B as its foci, as shown in Figure 26.
So far we have got all of the three Conic Section Curves as envelopes of straight lines. However, the sweeping curve for envelopes is in no way restricted to be a straight line. Circles, ellipses, and other curves can make sweeping curves for fantastic envelopes as well.
Envelope of circles
This section shows some interesting envelopes generated by moving a circle around.


In Figure 31, we begin with a base circle O, which is fixed in space, then select two points A and B on the base circle. Our sweeping circle is centered at A, and passes through B.
If we fix point B and slide point A along the fixed circle, circle A will sweep out a Cardioid, as shown in Figure 32.
The name "Cardioid" comes from the Greek word for "heartshaped". For more information about the Cardioid, please go to this page.


Similar to what we did in Figure 31, we still have a fixed base circle O, and a sweeping circle that has its center A sliding on the base circle. The only difference is that our sweeping circle is now tangent to a vertical line l, rather than passes through a fixed point.
The result is a Nephroid, which is the Greek word for "kidneyshaped". For more information about Nephroid please go here.


In Figure 35, we begin with a hyperbola, with points F1 and F2 as its foci and A as its center. Our sweeping circle has its center O on the hyperbola, and passes through A.
If we slide O along the hyperbola, we will get a Lemniscate as the envelope of the sweeping circle.
The Lemniscate is an eightshaped curve discovered by Jacob Bernoulli ^{[1]}. For more information about Lemniscates please go here.


In Figure 35, if instead of having A as center of the hyperbola, we move it to an arbitrary position between the hyperbola's two halves, then we will get a variation of "lemniscate", which has a funny shape like a bunny's ears.
More complicated envelopes
The following envelopes have more complicated mechanisms than previous ones. But as a result they are even more interesting.
1. The Astroid again, but this time using ellipses
Recall that in Figure 11, we showed how to construct an astroid using a line segment sliding on coordinate axes. Actually there is another way to generate the same astroid: using a family of ellipses.
The animation below shows this process. Here the variable parameter is c, which determines the shape of the ellipse. As we can see, when c varies continuously from 0 to 1, the varying ellipse sweeps out an Astroid.
2. A Deltoid as the envelope of WallaceSimson lines
The WallaceSimson line is related to an interesting theorem in geometry proposed by William Wallace in 1796. The theorem itself is not hard to prove, and with a little manipulation we can get one of the most beautiful envelopes out of it.
The following animation shows this process. Here M is the point that anchors the WallaceSimson line. When M moves around the circle, that line sweeps out a Deltoid:
This envelope was firstly discovered and proved by Swiss mathematician Jakob Steiner. In 1856 he published a paper, giving a lengthy proof of why we get a Deltoid when moving the WallaceSimson Line. A simplified version of this proof can be found here^{[3]}.
The Astroid, Cardioid, Nephroid, and Deltoid all belong to the Roulette Family, which means they can also be constructed by rolling one circle around another. For more information about Roulettes, please go to this page.
A More Mathematical Explanation
 Note: understanding of this explanation requires: *Calculus
At the beginning of this page, we gave the following definition:
 An envelope of a family of curves is the boundary of their sweeping area.
However, if we want a more mathematical explanation of envelope, we have to redefine it in a more mathematical way, because some problems arise with the original definition when we dive into more math:
First, we need a more general way to represent curves. Before this section we have been describing curves as graphs of a single variable function y= f(x). However, not all curves can be written in this form. For example, a circle of radius a cannot be represented as y= f(x) unless we use two functions, and . Same thing happens for ellipses, hyperbolas, and other complicated curves. So we need a more general expression to include them in our discussion.
Second, "boundary of the sweeping area" is a rough description in everyday language. It's not something that we can use to derive mathematical formula and equations. So we have to be clear about we mean by "sweep", "boundary", and so on.
In the rest of this section, we are going to deal with these two problems one by one, and show how can we get a good mathematical explanation of envelopes using the new definition.
Resolving the first problem: the power of level sets
The first problem is easily resolved if we describe 2D curves using level sets, rather than graphs of single variable functions y= f(x).
In Multivariable Calculus, the level set of a twovariable function F(x,y) at height C is defined as the set of points (x,y) that satisfy the condition F(x,y) = C. For example, instead of writing y = 2x  1 for a line, we could write 2x  y = 1, in which F(x,y) = 2x  y and C = 1.
In general, level sets are more powerful than graphs of single functions when we need to describe 2D curves, since all single variable functions y = f(x) can be written in the level set form F(x,y) = f(x)  y = 0 , but the converse is not true. For example, the circle in Figure 61, can not be rewritten as y = f(x) unless we use multiple functions. In a more extreme case, the level set x^{5} + y + cos y = 1 in Figure 62 is not even possible to be reduced to y = f(x) form, since there is no closedform, algebraic solution to this transcendental equation. For more about transcendental equations, please go to this page.


Because of these advantages of level sets, in the rest of this section we will use F(x,y) = C, rather than y = f(x), to describe a family of curves. At least for the purpose of envelopes, the method of level sets is sufficient to describe all 2D curves that we care about.
Resolving the second problem: the boundary condition
The next question is, given a family of level set curves F(x,y,t) = C with variable parameter t, how can we find its boundary and express it in mathematical language?
The answer is given by the boundary condition, which states that:
 For a family of level set curves F(x,y,t) = C with variable parameter t, it's envelope, or boundary of sweeping area, must satisfy the condition:
.
 For a family of level set curves F(x,y,t) = C with variable parameter t, it's envelope, or boundary of sweeping area, must satisfy the condition:
We will prove this condition using the implicit function theorem, which is an important theorem in calculus. The implicit function theorem states that, if we have a level set F(x,y) = C that satisfies some mild conditions, then y can be viewed as an implicit function of x, because their values are interrelated with each other. If the value of y changes, the value of x also has to change, since the condition F(x,y) = C must always be satisfied. As shown in the previous section, sometimes we can derive an explicit function y = f(x) from the level set, sometimes we can't. But the failure of deriving this explicit expression doesn't mean that x and y are unrelated. They are still related through this "implicit function".
This theorem can be generalized to functions of three or more variables. For example, in the level set F(x,y,t) = C , x can be viewed as an implicit function of y and t, y can be viewed as an implicit function of x and t, and so on. Moreover, if we fix one of the variables in this level set, then it's reduced to the 2variable case. Say, if we fix the value x in the lever set F(x,y,t) = C , then y is an implicit function of t.
With the implicit function theorem in hand, we are now equipped to prove the boundary condition, and find the envelope. Rather than looking at the whole family F(x,y,t) = C , we can fix the value of x, and focus on y as an implicit function of t. For example, in Figure 63, which is the ladder problem revisited, we can fix an x value by drawing a vertical line, so that each phase of the ladder intersects this line at a different point. The height, or ycoordinate of this point is an implicit function of the ladder's position, which is in turn determined by the variable parameter t. Now the problem is reduced to finding the highest and lowest ones among all these intersections, because they must lie on the envelope, as shown in Figure 64.


The maximum and minimum y values can be determined using the chain rule, which is a formula in calculus for computing the derivative of the composition of two or more functions. For example, if we have a function
in which and are differentiable functions of t. Then the chain rule claims that:
Same for function of three or more variables^{[4]} .
If we apply the chain rule to the level set with variable x fixed, we will get:
The expression didn't appear on the right side because variable x is fixed. Moreover, since , this expression can be further reduced to:
On the other hand, since is a constant function, we have:
So we can get:
in which is the derivative of the implicit function y(t).
For most envelopes, y is at its maximum or minimum as discussed before, so . And the previous equation is reduced to:
which is the boundary condition we are trying to prove.
Conclusion and Application
Now we have the family of level set curves:
and the boundary condition:
Since every point on the envelope must satisfy both equations, we can combine them to solve for a 2D envelope curve. However, the calculation involved is rather long and complicated, so here I will only prove a simple case: that the envelope of a sliding ladder is an Astroid.
Proof for the Astroid envelope
As shown in Figure 66, the length of the ladder is a. For simplicity we will only consider the envelope in the first quadrant.
Choose the xcoordinate of point A as the variable parameter t. So the ycoordinate of point B is
Thus the equation of line AB, our sweeping curve, is:
Differentiate Eq. 1 with regard to to get the boundary condition:
Move the x term to the right side to get a neater equation:
in which we introduced a new variable k to represent their values for convenience. As we have discussed before, Eq. 1 and Eq. 2 already define a 2D envelope curve. The following steps are just some manipulations that help us to eliminate t and get a direct relationship between x and y.
Substituting Eq. 2 into Eq. 1, we can get:
which gives us:
Substituting back into Eq. 2:
We can derive the values of t and from the equation above:
 , and
Substituting these values back into Eq.1:
Which leads to:
 , finally, the equation of an Astroid.
Other proofs are similar.^{[5]}
Why It's Interesting
Although the envelope concept looks like pure math, it does have some interesting applications in various areas, such as Microeconomics, Applied Physics, and String Art.
Application in Microeconomics: the Envelope Theorem
Economists often deal with maximization or minimization problems: to maximize benefit, minimize cost, maximize social revenue, and so on. However, the issue is that there are so many variable parameters in economics. How many men should I hire? How much land should I buy or rent? Should I invest more money to buy new machines, or should I just make with old ones? Because of all these variable parameters, economists often end up doing maximization or minimization of a family of curves, rather than a single curve (see Figure 71)
To analyze all these curves at once, economists introduced the Envelope Theorem, which allows them to find the envelope of a family of curves first, and then determine the maximum or minimum value on the envelope. Since no points go beyond the envelope, this point must be the absolute extremum among the whole family of curves.
For more about the Envelope Theorem, please go here^{[6]}.
Application in Physics: Envelope of Waves


In physics, if we combine two waves of almost the same wavelength and frequency, we will get a beating wave (see Figure 72). For such a wave, physicists usually care more about its envelope, rather than the wave itself, since the envelope is what people will actually hear, or see. For example, the two branches of a tuning fork are almost, but not exactly, identical. So if a tuning fork starts to vibrate, its two branches will produce two slightly different sound waves. The superposition of these two waves is a beating sound wave with varying amplitude. This is why people can hear "beats" when they strike a tuning fork.
A similar mechanism is used in AM (Amplitude Modulation) broadcasting. Different waves are superposed with each other to form a sinusoidal carrier wave with changing amplitude, which can be used to carry audio signals (see Figure 73). For more about broadcasting, please go here^{[7]}.
Application in String Art


String Art is a material representation of envelopes, in which people arrange colored straight strings to form complicated geometric figures.
For more about String Art please go here.
How the Main Image Relates
As pointed out in the main image, the envelope of all particles' trajectories in an exploding firework is a parabola. Here comes the explanation:
Figure 81 shows a simulation of the exploding process. Blue parabolas are trajectories of particles, and the red parabola is their envelope.
For the envelope to be parabolic, we have to make several assumptions:
 The firework is composed of many particles, each projected from the origin at the same time, with same velocity v.
 Particles are subject to constant gravity, with gravitational acceleration g.
 Air friction can be neglected. In fact, this turns out to be an contestable assumption. Most firework particles are relatively small and light, so they could be significantly deflected by air friction. However, the case with air friction is way too complicated for this page. Besides, air friction can be neglected, at least for some fireworks with big and heavy particles such as blueaerialshell. So we can still accept this assumption and see what happens.
With the assumptions above, we can write out the trajectory of one particular particle using simple mechanics:
 ,
in which θ is the angle of projection. For the physics behind this equation and more about projectile trajectory, please go here^{[8]}.
For now, let's leave Physics behind and focus on the curves themselves. In this trajectory, θ is the variable parameter. If we denote tanθ by t , we can write out a family of curves (in level set form):
Differentiate to get the boundary condition (see the More Mathematical Explanation section):
Substitute Eq 2 into Eq 1 to eliminate t. After doing some algebra we can get:
 ,
which gives us the parabolic envelope in Figure 81.
As we have discussed before, this is not true for all fireworks. Because of air friction, most fireworks have an envelope more like a sphere. Nonetheless, this parabolic pattern can be seen elsewhere, such as in fountains or explosions. This analysis is also useful in the study of safe domains^{[9]}in projectile motion.
Teaching Materials
 There are currently no teaching materials for this page. Add teaching materials.
Related Links
Additional Resources
 1.http://jwilson.coe.uga.edu/Texts.Folder/Envel/envelopes.html. I used this page as a starting point.
 2.http://poncelet.math.nthu.edu.tw/disk3/summer01/work/861/02/ex2.html. Here are some animations for more cool envelopes.
 3.http://www.dynamicgeometry.com/. This is a very helpful geometric software called Geometer's Sketchpad. I used this software to create most of my pictures.
References
 ↑ Lemniscate of Bernoulli, from Wikipedia. This is an introduction to Lemniscate and how it was discovered.
 ↑ Simson Line, from Wikipedia. This is a simple proof of the existence of WallaceSimson line.
 ↑ M. de Guzman, 2001, A simple proof of the Steiner theorem on the deltoid. This is a simplified version of Jakob Steiner's proof.
 ↑ The Chain Rule, from Wikipedia. This is a more thorough introduction to the chain rule in multivariable calculus.
 ↑ Envelope, from Wikipedia. This page was particularly helpful for me in the More Mathematical Explanation section. It also has proof for some more envelopes.
 ↑ Martin J. Osborne, Mathematical methods for economic theory: a tutorial by Martin J. Osborne, 2011. This is a brief introduction to Envelope Theorem in Microeconomics.
 ↑ Amplitude Modulation Broadcasting, from Wikipedia. This page is a more extensive introduction to AM broadcasting.
 ↑ Trajectory, from Wikipedia. This is the physics behind projectile motions.
 ↑ JeanMarc Richard, Safe domain and elementary geometry, 2008. This is a study about safe domains in projectile motion.
Future Directions for this Page
.
Leave a message on the discussion page by clicking the 'discussion' tab at the top of this image page.