Discussion:  All Topics 
Topic:  Algebra Textbook Recommendation 
Post a new topic to the General Discussion in Algebra discussion 

Subject:  RE: Algebra Textbook Recommendation 
Author:  cfriesen 
Date:  Jun 16 2007 
a. I like McDougal texts and have used them.
b. I sometimes wonder just how much students read the textbook. Does anyone
REALLY know??? I suspect there is much in present day texts that is never read
by students.
c. I wonder if all the color and glitz of the present day math books really
improves learning and retention.
d. While I have never been a zealot of Saxon, I have observed characteristics
in the program that I like: Students are required to REMAIN accountable for
many topics throughout the semester, as opposed to narrowly focusing upon
today's topic.
e. A great teacher can help students learn using McDougal texts. And a great
teacher can help students learn using Saxon texts. And a great teacher
overcomes or addresses the challenges I suggested in b. and d.
f. Parting shot: I have been depressed at the number of worksheets I have
observed math teachers use on a routine basis. Does this say something about
the text they are using? Some textbooks have a VERY VERY poor selection of
exercises (both range of exercises and amount of practice) which the student can
be assigned on a daily basis. Teachers using these "problempoor" texts are
almost required to use the publishers supplemental worksheets in order to give
students a meaningful and complete homework assignment.
 
Post a new topic to the General Discussion in Algebra discussion  
Visit related
discussions: Algebra  