View entire discussion
[<< prev] [ next >>]
From: vm To: Teacher2Teacher Public Discussion Date: 2005100100:32:24 Subject: Re: accelerated math program Thank you for posting your message. Everybody seems to praise this system from what I've read about it. I felt like I was alone in thinking that it's a horrible way to teach math. I'm not a teacher but I am a parent. My son is in the 5th grade. At the end of the 4th grade his class had just started on simple division. By the end of summer, I had him working on long division with multiple numbers. Now, he's failing math. I couldn't understand it... One night I had him bring home his practice sheet so that I could see what he was doing wrong. He had everything correct. The next day, he came home and said he missed eight of them! I'm a chemical engineer - I know my math and he didn't miss one of the problems. Then he told me about the scan cards so I asked him to bring one home. Apparently they aren't allowed to, but he (covertly) brought one so that I could see what he was doing wrong. Again, he worked out the answers on the worksheet and all were correct, but when he went to fill in the answers on the scan card... I don't know how they expect young children to completely fill in the small ovals or erase a million times or keep track of where they were at. He spent 5 minutes arguing with me that he had not marked both A and D on the same problem number! He honestly could not see it. He'd skip whole sections of writing down answers or repeat what he had already written down. No wonder he's failing! Plus, at school, he's in a hurry to finish because he can't go out for recess unless it's complete. I absolutely do not agree with this way of teaching! My love for math grew because of the wonderful patterns. You learned one problem, did similar problems, then it changed slightly and you learned how to adapt what you already know. By this method you learn not only the math, but also how to adapt your thinking. This is not a way to get children to love math or to learn how to think for themselves. What we are losing by doing this are the future scientists, mathematicians, engineers, and math teachers!
Math Forum Home || The Math Library || Quick Reference || Math Forum Search