Teacher2Teacher 
Q&A #6281 
View entire discussion [<< prev] [ next >>]
From: Carl Gladish <carl_gladish@hotmail.com> To: Teacher2Teacher Public Discussion Date: 2001111801:41:09 Subject: Re: Regroup or Borrow The lefttoright method is correct, but there is a possible complication that could make the method more difficult to learn properly. Basically, in the righttoleft method, you only borrow if you "have" to. That is, you only borrow if the digit on the top is smaller than the digit on the right. If you borrow first going from lefttoright, you may create a situation where the number on top is more than 9 larger than the number on the bottom so that after subtracting you have, say 12. Then you have to carry the one to the left and increase the already large mess by scratching out the previous top digit and increasing it by one. Actually, the whole problem could cascade backwards so that every number that is written on top has to be rewritten again! For example, say the problem is 8998  121  Then after doing the lefttoright borrowing you get: 7 18 18 18  1 2 1  Now, you simply have to go from righttoleft, or the whole thing is just stupid. What you get, even going righttoleft is too hard to write without using MS Paint. Please don't recommend that students use this method! Carl Gladish
Post a reply to this message

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]
Math Forum Home 
The Math Library 
Quick Reference 
Math Forum Search