Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



Flies, trains, and series summation
Posted:
Oct 26, 1999 1:13 PM


[sci.physics.research removed]
In sci.physics Chris Hillman <hillman@math.washington.edu> wrote: > On 22 Oct 1999, Phillip Helbig wrote: >> The problem being: Two trains are 60 miles apart and approaching each >> other at 30 miles per hour. There is a fly flying between the >> cowcatchers of each train, at 60 miles per hour, back and forth, turning >> around immediately. What is the total distance covered by the fly
> The problem you mention certainly strikes me as much too simple to have > the ring of truth, since anyone could sum that series in their head in a > few seconds!
Then, "ian" <walkersystems@one.net.au> wrote: > why sum a series? > it takes the trains 1 hour to hit, the fly travels at 60 m/hr so the fly > flies 60 miles...
When I heard about this puzzle long time ago I got the idea that perhaps this way you can sum some complicated series using the following procedure: Construct (complicated) trainsfly path such that the fly, flying to and fro, travels distances equal to the terms of your series. Than the distance traveled by train(s) equals the sum of the series. Now, I was too lazy (and mathematically ignorant) to investigate into this idea but I'd love to hear if this wouldn't work and why (too trivial probably).
  Kresimir Kumericki kkumer@phy.hr http://www.phy.hr/~kkumer/ Theoretical Physics Department, University of Zagreb, Croatia 



