Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



Re: Landau letter, Re: Mathematica as a New Approach...
Posted:
Aug 30, 2012 4:08 AM


On Wednesday, August 15, 2012 1:31:53 AM UTC6, Andrzej Kozlowski wrote:
> I agree with your interpretation of Landau's letter but I also think your
> remarks about mathematics miss the point of what mathematicians do.
I know what mathematicians do. Finding connections between ideas is at the core of mathematics. The best mathematicians (von Neumann, for example)follow those connections wherever they lead, and don't stop at arbitrary borders. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=rethinkinglabelsboostscreativity has some relevance here.
> Mathematicians do not concern themselves with the physical universe  if
> they did they would be something else. The results which they prove are
> meaningful within their own realm. The exact nature of this "meaning" is
> complicated, but it essentially relates to "procedures" (how arguments
> are conducted) than any physical reality. A great deal of mathematics
> (for example, almost all of probability theory) is concerned with
> "infinity", which arguably has no physical meaning at all.
Except that in many cases, it has been physical scientists who *introduced*mathematicians to various uses of infinity (differentials, Fourier analysis, delta functions, ...). But that's history.
It is also clear from history that mathematics developed from very concrete foundations in things like counting and measurement. It is incomprehensibl e to me that many mathematicians wish to deny this, preferring to believe in Platonic fairy tales. A nasty consequence of this denial was the 1960's "New Math" curriculum for American schoolchildren. Supposed to strengthen math comprehension, it did exactly the opposite.
I cringe when I hear a mathematician talk about Fourier analysis as being about functions in L2. That notion ignores out a large part of the application space: "carrier waves", "flicker noise", delta functions, ... Here we see mathematicians willfully avoiding *meaningful* infinity.
...
...
...
Let me just point out that the origin of this interesting and passionate discussion was the question of what should be the content and tools of the mathematical education for students in nonmathematical specialities at present, observing that since long computers have become the reality of our world.
Best, Alexei
Alexei BOULBITCH, Dr., habil. IEE S.A. ZAE Weiergewan, 11, rue Edmond Reuter, L5326 Contern, LUXEMBOURG
Office phone : +35224542566 Office fax: +35224543566 mobile phone: +49 151 52 40 66 44
email: alexei.boulbitch@iee.lu<mailto:alexei.boulbitch@iee.lu>



