Date: Sep 24, 2012 2:31 AM
Author: James Waldby
Subject: Re: Binary or Logical Selection : Given an array A and a binary <br> orlogical vector S, how do I select the rows of A when S = 1 or True ?
On Sun, 23 Sep 2012 22:00:15 +0200, clicliclic wrote:

> Beau Webber schrieb:

>> Given a 3 column array A of x,y,z numbers, defining a set of spatial

>> coordinates, and a binary or logical selection vector S (with as many

>> elements as rows in A) :

>>

>> How do I express the operation of selecting an array R with the set of

>> those co-ordinates in A where S is 1 (or true) ?

>>

>> In Apl I write this as R <- S /[1] A .

>>

>> But a referee of a paper is asking that I express this in standard

>> maths, and I have not yet managed to find an appropriate mathematical

>> expression.

...

> I can imagine that referees don't like mathematical explanations in

> terms of APL - unless yours is a paper about APL (does the language

> still exist?). But I can't think of an elegant way to express this in

> standard vector notation either. This newsgroup is only concerned with

> the development and application of computer-algebra systems like Maxima

> or Maple, I am therefore widening the audience to include sci.math.

>

> Can anybody help the original poster?

Perhaps write something like following, in which the form p_i_j

stands for p_{i_j} and the parenthesized lists stand for vectors

of points p_i.

Suppose A = (p_1, p_2, ... p_n). Let R = (p_i_1, p_i_2, ... p_i_k)

where i_j < i_{j+1} for all the j, and i \in { i_j } iff S_i = 1.

--

jiw