Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



[apcalculus] Re: Locally Linear
Posted:
Nov 22, 2000 1:38 PM


Doug Kuhlmann wrote:
> >Is the function y = x^(1/3) considered to be locally linear at x = 0? > > > >Mary Thomas > > > I would come down on the side of saying that while y=x(1/3) has a vertical > tangent at x=0, it is not locally linear there since there is no > approximating linear function at x=0. Maybe we should just say that the > function is locally vertical at the origin and locally affine elsewhere.
Thoughtful response to an interesting question. How about thisthe function whose graph is described by y = x^3 has the xaxis as its ÃÂbestÃÂ local linear approximator at the origin. I would propose that ÃÂbest linear approximatorÃÂ characterizes tangent lines. Then, consider mapping the graph described by y = x^3 and its local linear approximator at (0,0) with a reflection in the y = x line. Would this not lead to the conclusion that the yaxis is the best local linear approximator (that is, the tangent line) for the graph described by y = x^(1/3) at (0,0). In this case we would simple ackowledge that the best linear approximator does not happen to be the graph of a function.
I have mentioned in a post some time ago that Donald Kreider at Dartmouth created an interesting investigation using a graphing calculator of how the tangent line to a particular funciton at a particular point compares to a line with a slightly different slope through the same point. Each year I take the time with my AB students to run a variation of his investigation. The students see for themselves that the tangent line dominates all competitors in a neat visual way. This has led me to appreciate in a new way the reasonableness of characterizing tangent lines as "BEST" linear approximators.
Sincerely,
Richard Sisley
> > > Doug > > Doug Kuhlmann > Math Department > Phillips Academy > 180 Main Street > Andover, MA 01810 > dkuhlmann@andover.edu > >  > You are currently subscribed to apcalculus as: keckcalc@earthlink.net > To unsubscribe send a blank email to leaveapcalculus5913831W@list.collegeboard.org
 You are currently subscribed to apcalculus as: archive@mathforum.com To unsubscribe send a blank email to leaveapcalculus5913831W@list.collegeboard.org



