Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



Re: Halmos is Spiraling
Posted:
Jun 9, 1995 12:42 PM


At the college level, spiraling definitely works. BUT the student has to struggle hard with the idea for several days or a week. Typically, after the student has moved on, about 3 weeks later, she can't remember what was so hard about the concept. Unfortunately, college courses tend to be compressed into 10 or 15 weeks, and summer classes are even worse. So the material at the end often doesn't get absorbed.
The problem with writing a book this way is that Ch. 1 is very polished and the last chapter is very rough. I have encountered a lot of math books like this.
Susan Addington (addington@gallium.csusb.edu) Math Department, California State University San Bernardino, CA 92407 World Wide Web: http://www.math.csusb.edu/
On Fri, 9 Jun 1995, Alfred Barron (908) 7044102 wrote: > over, he claims that he has written all of his > books in this manner; i.e., write the first chapter, > the rewrite the first chapter. Write the second > chapter, then rewrite the first and second chapters. > Write the third chapter, then rewrite the first, > second and third chapters, etc.. So here the method > of spiraling underlies the structure of his book as > well. This is what he started doing when he wrote > his first book (Set Theory). > > How did he start doing this ? I don't recall what he > wrote, if anything. But he did note that John von > Neuman wrote and lectured this way (Halmos was his > assistant as a young post doc). > > Al BArron > barron@alloy.bitnet have a good weekend! > >



