Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Replies: 0

 Pat Ballew Posts: 64 Registered: 12/6/04
Posted: Jun 15, 1995 12:16 AM

I guess I have to agree with Dan that there are some basic Ideas that have
to be developed prior to any real practical applications of mathematics. I
think I have an example close to home for most of us...this weeks POW on the
Geometry forum. The problem is a simple triangle problem given one side and
two perpendicular segments to the other two sides. The reason it relates,
IMO, to this discussion, is that to solve it most of my students had to
recognize opportunities to use the Pythagorean Thm, the law of Sines, and if
they wanted an exact answer (and they really do see that as more pleasing
now) they also had to recognize an opportunity to use the expansion of
Sin(A+B). None of this is directed in the problem, and without the depth of
experience that comes from the "drudgery" of practicing these skills I don't
think they would have recognized the opportunity to use them..
One of the things I think makes these skills "available" on call is
regular practice with a wide range of "short, quick learning experiences
focusing on each of these as a particular goal". I often use the term
"homework problems" as a general description of these practice sessions. I
don't feel any software I can imagine would replace all the analytic
thinking that had to go into this particular problem, and I don't yet know
of a better way of developing the capacity to make those decisions than the
repetitive practice mentioned above.
I am thrilled when my students can show me a new way to solve a
question on the sketchpad, or ti-85 or derive or .... but what thrills me
more is that the software and technology serves both to reinforce the ideas
learned by "drudgery", because they are the tools to open up additional
ideas which the students discover for themselves. They serve both to
validate the hard work that the students have done before, but reward them
with the excitement of new discoveries.

I'm off to the states in three days so if I do not respond.....QED

Pat Ballew "lovin' what I do"
Edgren HS, Misawa, Japan
ballewp@emh.misawa.af.mil