Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



Newsletter: Math Forum Internet News No. 2.12 (March 24)
Posted:
Mar 22, 1997 11:20 PM


24 March 1997 Vol.2, No.12
THE MATH FORUM INTERNET NEWS
SCORE Mathematics  Nils Ahbel  Plausibility Arguments
SCORE MATHEMATICS
http://www.kings.k12.ca.us/math/
From The Schools of California Online Resource for Educators. The contents and links are intended to reflect the California Mathematics Framework.
An archive of Internet Math Resources for grades K4, 58, and 912 may be browsed or searched. It includes information on assessment and education organizations, and features a database of math lessons.
\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/
NILS AHBEL  KENT SCHOOL
http://www.kent.pvt.k12.ct.us/fachmpag/ahbeln/homepage.htm
Nils Ahbel teaches mathematics at Kent School in Connecticut. He and his students have generated some interesting new math materials for the secondary school level:
UNI AND BIVARIATE DATA ANALYSIS
A fall term computer project for Nils Ahbel's honors class in Functions, Trigonometry and Statistics. Students chose a topic, searched the Internet for relevant data, performed a statistical analysis, and displayed the results.
 NBA draft picks by Mike Harley '98.  German traffic safety by Philipp Hasskamp '97.  Ice cream consumption by Sarah O'Neil '98.
EXCEL FILES FOR THE MATH CLASSROOM
Microsoft Excel files to download: annual vs. compound interest, arithmetic and geometric sequences and series, height of a falling object over time, Pascal's Triangle, polynomial differences, a simulation of rolling two dice and one about a family with three children, synthetic division, transformations, and trigonometric modeling. Images of sample output let you view the content of many modules before downloading them.
GEOMETER'S SKETCHPAD FILES
Downloadable v.3.0 files, with samples for viewing. Subjects include a variety of tessellations, and Versiera, better known as the Witch of Agnesi.
The work of some of Nils' students is among the pages featured in the Math Forum's Student Showcase:
http://forum.swarthmore.edu/students/showcase/
\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/
PLAUSIBILITY ARGUMENTS: A MATHTEACH DISCUSSION
What is really meant by the phrase "plausiblity argument"? We can see just how thorny this question really is by recasting it: What is a proof?  Lou Talman
On March 7th Ron Ward initiated a lively discussion on the MATHTEACH mailing list (formerly NCTML) about student assessment as addressed in the 1989 NCTM Evaluation Standards.
http://forum.swarthmore.edu/epigone/mathteach/jaltweldjax
Ward's message focuses on Standard 7  Reasoning: "What is really meant by a 'PLAUSIBILITY argument'? What is the difference between 'use reasoning to develop plausible arguments' and 'use deductive reasoning to construct valid arguments'?"
The discussion ranges through a number of issues: Can a good teacher be precise without being pedantic? Aren't almost all proofs really plausibility arguments? Is rigorous proof still important? What is the role of logic? How should we deal with students who invent plausible, convincing false proofs?
Ted Alper contributes a simple false proof that constructs a triangle with two right angles, and Andre Toom offers a false proof that an arbitrary triangle is isosceles.
See "Plausibility Arguments" in the Math Forum archives:
http://forum.swarthmore.edu/epigone/mathteach/fersusnim
\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/
CHECK OUT OUR WEB SITE:
The Math Forum http://forum.swarthmore.edu/ Ask Dr. Math http://forum.swarthmore.edu/dr.math/ Problem of the Week http://forum.swarthmore.edu/geopow/ Internet Resources http://forum.swarthmore.edu/~steve/ Join the Math Forum http://forum.swarthmore.edu/join.forum.html
SEND COMMENTS TO comments@forum.swarthmore.edu
_o \o_ __ \ / __ o _ o/ \o/ __ __/ \__/o \o  o/ o/__ /\ /  \ \ / \ / \ /o\ / \  \ /  / \ / \
The Math Forum ** 24 March 1997
You will find this newsletter, a FAQ, and subscription directions archived at
http://forum.swarthmore.edu/electronic.newsletter/



