Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Legal Problems With Wrong Math?
Replies: 9   Last Post: Dec 18, 2002 4:11 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Bill Taylor Posts: 1,909 Registered: 12/8/04
Re: Legal Problems With Wrong Math?
Posted: Dec 18, 2002 4:11 AM

|> > No, but there's a famous case of someone being thrown overboard to drown,
|> > on account of having correctly proved a CORRECT theorem.
|> >
|> Sounds fishy. Was it a deep theorem?

HAH! They were just surfing the knowledge wave of their time, picking up
the odd pretty shell on the shore, while the great ocean of truth waited
unexplored before them. (Hmmm... didn't someone else say that?)

Anyway, the Pythagoreans clearly regarded this root-two business as
a barnacle on the hull of their geometrical vessel of perfection.

Hey - it occurs to me that the Pythagoreans missed out on a great chance to
have a particular animal as their symbolic beast.... the STARFISH !

`. '
` `. ,''
``. ` . ; ':
` ` `.,' ' '
` `. , ' ' <--- this one could double as
: , . : Tolkien's sketch of Mt Erebor
, ', ' . ` . `.
,,',_ . ` .`.
,,,' - . , `. `..
,' `. : ' `-.:
` `: `
`.,
`
/ //\ // \ -===========//=================-
`!:. // \\ ,;!'
`!:. // WFCT \\ ,;!'
`!:. ~~~~ \\!'
//`!:. ,;!'\ // ` ,;;' \ // ,;!' :. \ // ,;!' `!:. \ //,;!' `!:.\ /;!' `!. ' `

Date Subject Author
12/16/02 Leroy Quet
12/16/02 G.E. Ivey
12/17/02 Bill Taylor
12/17/02 tend
12/17/02 Virgil
12/17/02 Robert Israel
12/17/02 James Buddenhagen
12/18/02 Bill Taylor
12/17/02 Virgil
12/18/02 Bill Taylor