Date: 10/13/98 at 18:19:00 From: Sabina Subject: Algebra: Thinking problem. Hi Dr. Math! I have difficulty doing a thinking problem in Algebra. Here is the problem: The Truel. A truel is similar to a duel, except there are three participants rather than two. One morning Mr. Black, Mr. Gray, and Mr. White decide to resolve a conflict by trueling with pistols until only one of them survives. Mr. Black is the worst shot, hitting his target on average only one time in three. Mr. Gray is a better shot, hitting his target two times out of three. Mr. White is the best shot, hitting his target every time. To make the truel fairer, Mr. Black is allowed to shoot first, followed by Mr. Gray (if he is still alive), followed by Mr. White (if he is still alive), and around again until only one of them is alive. The question is this: Where should Mr. Black aim his first shot? I think that participants would have the same distance between each other. Maybe Mr. Black should aim his first shot straight between Mr. Gray and Mr. White, so he would probably shoot one of them. But I am not sure, and I need logical reasons to support my answer. Thank you very much.
Date: 10/20/98 at 20:03:42 From: Doctor Santu Subject: Re: Algebra: Thinking problem. Hello, Sabina. What an interesting question. One never knows when one might be in a truel! Might as well be prepared. Try working backward from the end of the Truel. You can work backward from the scenarios where Black gets killed, and figure what he should not have done, or work backward from the scenarios where he lives, and see what he did right. We'll start off using the latter method. Suppose Black survives. This means he didn't get shot by Grey, and he didn't get shot by White. White never misses. Why didn't Black get shot by White? He must have been shot by someone else. Who could it be? Could it be Grey? I really should leave the reasoning to you with that little hint - work backward from the fact that you want Black to survive. Dr. Santu, The Math Forum Check out our web site! http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.