Limits to Paper Folding
Date: 05/09/2002 at 23:16:06 From: E Neville-Lamb Subject: Limits It is said that a piece of paper can be folded not more than nine times. I understand that the thickness increases as a geometrical progression, but what is the determining limit and how is it established? Why nine times and not eight or ten?
Date: 05/10/2002 at 09:16:10 From: Doctor Peterson Subject: Re: Limits Hi, E. It's just a rule of thumb, not an absolute limit; I thought I'd heard something more like 7, but it depends on the size of the paper and how hard you work to fold it. Consider both the thickness and the width of the folded paper after N folds, if it starts with thickness t and width w; I'll first assume we are always folding in the same direction, making a narrow strip with a constant thickness, rather than always folding across the narrow dimension as you would in reality. Then after N folds, the thickness is 2^N t and the width is 2^-N w, since the former doubles each time and the latter is halved. The ratio of thickness to width is then (2^N t)/(2^-N w) = 2^(2N) t/w So, what is a reasonable ratio to start with? Suppose we use 8.5 by 11 paper and treat 11 inches as the width; and suppose that 500 sheets are 1 inch thick, so t is 0.002 inch. Then t/w is 0.002/11 = 0.0002. Let's suppose for very thin paper it is 0.0001. After 7 folds the ratio becomes 2^14 * 0.0001 = 1.6 That means the thickness is more than the width! And that is what limits the folding; if you manage to fold it at all, it's hard to think of it as folding when it's all bend and no flat paper. Now suppose we took the same paper and started with, say, a 50-foot width; that's about 50 times as wide as our single sheet, so the initial t/w is 1/50 as big. Notice that 50 is less than 2^6, so just three more folds will make up for the difference; after 10 folds the ratio becomes 2^20 * 0.000002 = 2 So depending on exactly when you consider it impossible to go on, and just how big the paper is to start with, you might get up to 10 folds, but that's pretty extreme. If you take into account the fact that you will really be folding in alternating directions to use up both width and height, you can refine this a little. We can say that the width will be cut in half every two folds rather than every fold, while the thickness continues to be doubled every fold; so the thickness ratio will really be (2^N t) / (2^(N/2) w) = 2^(3N/2) t/w For our last example, assuming a 50 by 50 foot sheet (!), after 10 folds the ratio will be 2^15 * 0.000002 = 0.066 but after 12 folds it will be 8 times as great, or 0.5. This is a significant improvement, and we can still get another fold or two out of it. But of course, I chose a ridiculously large sheet! The important point, of course, is that to get just one more fold out of a sheet, you will have to multiply the width by 2^(3/2) = 2.8, so the width, within reasonable bounds, has little effect. - Doctor Peterson, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/
Date: 03/25/2003 at 05:19:33 From: Britney Gallivan Subject: Folding Paper in Half 12 Times I originally did work on the paper-folding problem, solved for limits for several cases, checked the Internet, etc. and wrote a paper on the limits of folding paper. I had the paper and work I wrote checked by Professor Benjamin of Harvey Mudd College in February of 2002. I then published the booklet and have sent it to quite a few mathematicians. I asked for permission from Dr. Ken to quote the only Dr. Math work then available (31 Dec 1994, PaperFolding). Dr. Ken's work did not describe actual limits. I was checking the Web and noticed Dr. Peterson's article "Limits to Paper Folding" done in May of 2002. This was after I had derived equations and folded a piece of paper in half 12 times per calculated limits and written my booklet on the subject. If it had been written before my publication I certainly would have included it as a reference. It does address the correct approach. For your interest, the booklet I made is described at: How to Fold Paper in Half Twelve Times - Historical Society of Pomona Valley http://www.osb.net/Pomona/12times.htm Thank you. It is a quality Web site that you operate. Britney Gallivan
Search the Dr. Math Library:
Ask Dr. MathTM
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.