Can Even and Odd Numbers Be Negative?Date: 04/11/2006 at 07:12:07 From: Sarah Subject: definition of even and odd number Can even or odd numbers be non-positive? For example, is 0 even? Is -4 even? Is -5 odd? Some teachers say that even and odd numbers do not include negative integers, but some teachers say they are included. Date: 04/11/2006 at 08:04:09 From: Doctor Rick Subject: Re: definition of even and odd number Hi, Sarah. No problem arises when the definition of even and odd is extended from the positive integers to all integers, so I see no reason not to do so. An even number is an integer that is divisible by 2 (that is, it can be written as 2 times some integer); an odd number is an integer that is not divisible by 2. In contrast, if we try to extend the concept to non-integer rational numbers, we encounter difficulties; any definition that is self- consistent is not particularly useful. Therefore we restrict evenness and oddness to integers; the number 1/2 is neither even nor odd. I'd like to hear the reasons that those teachers give for not including negative integers. This question comes up a lot (usually in the form "is zero even, odd, or neutral?"), and I have yet to see a good reason. - Doctor Rick, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/ Date: 04/12/2006 at 07:06:55 From: Sarah Subject: definition of even and odd number Some teachers say that we only need the concept of even and odd numbers when we count. It is meaningless to extend our discussion of even and odd to non-positive integers. Are these teachers right? What is the use of extending the discussion of evenness and oddness to non-positive integers? Date: 04/12/2006 at 08:38:27 From: Doctor Rick Subject: Re: definition of even and odd number Hi, Sarah. I think we must distinguish between "meaningless" and "useless". Extending the definition of evenness and oddness to non-positive integers is not meaningless, because it is self-consistent; as long as a definition doesn't break anything, it imparts meaning "by definition". "Useless," on the other hand, is a word that pure mathematicians don't care for; many mathematical concepts were developed without thought of whether they had any use, but often applications of the concepts have appeared long afterward. The terms "even" and "odd" do have their origin in counting: if you count 22 objects into two piles, the piles are the same size (even), whereas if you count 23 objects into two piles, you get one left over (odd). The most frequent usage of the words "even" and "odd" is certainly in the domain of non-negative integers. (I want to include 0 as an even number, because if you have no apples and you divide them between two people, you don't have any apples left over.) I could point out other ways in which mathematicians use the words "even" and "odd", without reference to numbers at all: there are even and odd functions and even and odd permutations. Both grow out of the non-negative-integer sense of even and odd: a polynomial consisting of only even powers of the variable (including 0) is even; a permutation that can be expressed as a product of an even number of transpositions (including no transpositions) is even. My principal difficulty with those who ask, "Is -2 an even number?" and answer "no", is that once a negative integer is brought into the discussion, there is no reason to say it isn't even or odd. The only reason to restrict the even and odd numbers to positive integers is when no other numbers are in view; for instance, when counting or when factoring numbers. Then, even numbers mean *positive* even numbers, simply because positive numbers are the only numbers that exist, for the present purpose. But when you ask about a negative number, it is natural to apply the definition to that domain: an even integer is one that can be expressed as the product of 2 with some integer (not only a positive integer). What would be gained by saying that there are three classes of integers: even integers, odd integers, and negative integers? One interesting thing about the even integers is that this set is closed under addition and multiplication: if you add two even integers, you get an even integer, and if you multiply two even integers, you get an even integer. The set of even integers is thus a useful example in abstract algebra. Looking through my abstract algebra textbook, I find this: "Let E = {even integers} = {2n | n is in Z}. Then (E, +, *} is an infinite commutative ring without identity where + and * are ordinary addition and multiplication." There is one example of mathematicians applying the term "even" to all integers, and also one demonstration of the usefulness of the concept to mathematicians. The set of even integers is interesting. To me, that is sufficient justification. - Doctor Rick, The Math Forum http://mathforum.org/dr.math/ Date: 04/13/2006 at 07:54:21 From: Sarah Subject: Thank you (definition of even and odd number) Thank you very much for answering my questions in detail. I learned a lot! |
Search the Dr. Math Library: |
[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]
Ask Dr. Math^{TM}
© 1994- The Math Forum at NCTM. All rights reserved.
http://mathforum.org/dr.math/