You are not logged in.
login | register

Discussion: All Topics
Topic: More on Drill and Kill, practice and learning

Post a new topic to the Research Area Discussion discussion
<< see all messages in this topic
<previous message | next message >

Subject:   RE: More on Drill and Kill, practice and learning
Author: Mathman
Date: Jan 18 2005
On Jan 18 2005, rabeldin wrote:
> At
> one local college, I had a student who came up after class and said,
> "Why do I have to think to pass your course? I get along fine with
> memorization in all the others."

The course in question was an
> introduction to computing for business applications. I admit that I
> injected some philosophical questions into the course, like "You
> need to consider your objectives before you settle on a course of
> action."

This might sound like it's all about me, but it's not.  It's just recognition of
the problem from the point of view of both teacher and student:

I see the problem, and might have been your worst student, since I tend to barge
right into it [and have paid the price at times], but there are differences in
people.  Some can see 3D in their heads [I'm one] while others have to go
through stages to get there.  If you want to accomplish your wishes and have
students do flow-charts etc, it might be necessary to make part of their
objective such that there is 5% for the initial presentation of ideas [The TOE
chart in VB], and 95% for the actual program development.  Unfortunately, I'd
lose 5% off the top.  The only analogy I can think of was the old necessity to
make a Euclid reference for each line of proof in geometry.  I couldn't recall
if it was Book I or Book XII, so lost marks constantly.  It also slowed me down
considerably.  However, when let loose [I just decided to ignore the required
Euclid statements and just write down the logical proof statements] it was a
flood, and Euclidean Geometry has long been my favourite, and I've solved
problems that completely stumped others.  That's it really ...different strokes
for different folk.


Reply to this message          Quote this message when replying?
yes  no
Post a new topic to the Research Area Discussion discussion

Discussion Help