Teacher2Teacher |
Q&A #1154 |
From: Beth
To: Teacher2Teacher Public Discussion
Date: 2003112423:56:03
Subject: Front-End Estimation - is it really helpful?
I had my first experience using front-end estimation with my third grader this evening. My son is currently making A's in math, but the usual homework session ends with him throwing his pencil across the floor, and declaring that I have no clue about how to do math. Oh the joys of parenthood! His current math method gives no instructions/examples for the parent and student to follow, and yet many of the problems, especially those that require estimation or front-end estimation are subject to a great deal of interpretation. Here is an example from tonight's homework: Use front-end estimation to estimate each sum. 334 + 865 + 202 = My estimate would be 1400. My son's estimate was 1300. After I reviewed his other answers to the first twelve problems, and talked with him about the problems that he completed during class, I realized that we were adding only the digits in the first column, and replacing the other columns with zeros. My son is slightly frustrated that he had to explain this to me, and we move on. Here comes problem #13. Is the sum of $4.32 +$6.90 +$7.86 greater than $17.00? Explain. My son says no. He is still using the concept of front-end estimation that he used in the earlier problems, so he has decided that 4+6+7+=17. After I politely disagree that the sum is greater than $17, and try to provide an explanation on paper, his is no longer in the mood to continue the assignment. I write a letter to his teacher, wishing for a math method that provided slightly better examples. I consider myself to be an educated adult. When did third grade math become this complicated? I decided to look up front-end estimation on-line, and I find this website. After reading some of the other comments that were posted, I see several different interpretations of FEE. Adding the first two columns would seem to provide a more accurate answer, but this is apparently not how it was explained to my son. It is my feeling that FEE would be helpful only for the young student who is trying to achieve a very broad estimate. If we were at the supermarket, rounding to the closet currency would seem more appropriate. It's good to know that I am not the only parent who is questioning the method behind the madness! Gail, I agree with your concept of using a variety of methods, because I feel that sometimes teachers limit themselves to one, and then are not able to help the student who responds better to a different type of approach. I applaud your desire to help the students really understand the math. It appears to me, however, that in your examples, you are combining FEE and rounding. Thank you all for sharing your desire to better understand the process and provide the best education for our children. Happy mathing! Beth
Post a reply to this message
Post a related public
discussion message
Ask Teacher2Teacher a new question
[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]
Math Forum Home ||
The Math Library ||
Quick Reference ||
Math Forum Search